Department of Nutrition, Institute of Basic Medical Sciences, University of Oslo, Norway.
Department of Child and Adolescent Health, Norwegian Directorate of Health, Norway.
Scand J Public Health. 2021 Jun;49(4):358-368. doi: 10.1177/1403494820972590. Epub 2020 Dec 10.
This article reports on the development and reliability of two questionnaires that measure adherence to the Norwegian National Guideline on Food and Meals in School among primary schools and after-school services. Questionnaires for school principals and after-school leaders were developed systematically, using the following steps: (a) selection of scope, questions and adherence values; (b) face validity testing through expert review of initial drafts; (c) content validity testing through 19 cognitive interviews; (d) assessment of test-retest reliability in samples of principals ( = 54) and after-school leaders ( = 47); and (e) development of adherence indices. The cognitive interviews led to substantial revisions of the draft questionnaires, increasing content validity through improved relevance and clarity. Test-retest assessment showed that Cohen's κ ranged from -0.03 to 1.0 for principals and from -0.05 to 0.98 for after-school leaders, with 64 and 53% of values rated as 'substantial' or better. Percentage agreement averaged 85% among principals and 82% among after-school leaders. Intraclass correlation for the adherence index scores was 0.84 for principals and 0.91 for after-school leaders. Guideline adherence had a wide range in our samples, with an average of 71% for schools and 76% for after-school services. .
本文报告了两项针对小学和课后服务机构中遵守挪威国家学校食品和膳食指南的调查问卷的开发和可靠性。校长和课后服务负责人的问卷是通过以下步骤系统开发的:(a)选择范围、问题和依从性值;(b)通过专家对初步草案的审查进行表面有效性测试;(c)通过 19 次认知访谈进行内容有效性测试;(d)在校长样本(n=54)和课后服务负责人样本(n=47)中评估测试-重测信度;以及 (e) 制定依从性指数。认知访谈导致草案问卷进行了大量修订,通过提高相关性和清晰度来提高内容有效性。测试-重测评估显示,校长的 Cohen's κ 值范围为-0.03 至 1.0,课后服务负责人的 Cohen's κ 值范围为-0.05 至 0.98,64%和 53%的数值被评为“中等”或更好。校长的平均百分比一致性为 85%,课后服务负责人的平均百分比一致性为 82%。校长和课后服务负责人的依从性指数得分的组内相关系数分别为 0.84 和 0.91。我们的样本中,指南的依从性范围很广,学校的平均依从率为 71%,课后服务的平均依从率为 76%。