McKenna Leanda J, Bonnett Luke, Panzich Kelly, Lim Jacinta, Hansen Snorre K, Graves Anna, Jacques Angela, Williams Sian A
School of Physiotherapy and Exercise Science, Curtin University, Perth, Australia.
Department of Medical Imaging, Curtin University, Perth, Australia.
Phys Ther. 2021 Mar 3;101(3). doi: 10.1093/ptj/pzaa208.
Serratus anterior (SA) muscle activation may be decreased with subacromial pain syndrome. The purpose of this study was to determine whether the addition of real-time ultrasound (RTUS) visual feedback increased activation of SA in adults with painful shoulders in comparison to manual facilitation alone.
This assessor-blinded, 2-period, randomized cross-over trial was conducted in a university medical imaging laboratory. Adults with mild-moderate unilateral subacromial pain received both interventions in random order with at least 1-week washout between interventions. Fourteen participants were randomized to receive manual facilitation with RTUS first, and 13 were randomized to receive manual facilitation alone first. Fifteen repetitions of a supine ``serratus punch'' were facilitated by RTUS visual feedback with manual facilitation or by manual facilitation alone. Levels of SA activation via surface electromyography were normalized to a maximum voluntary isometric contraction.
A total of 25 participants completed the full trial of both interventions. Data from 25 participant periods for RTUS with manual facilitation and data from 26 participant periods for manual facilitation only were analyzed. The predicted marginal mean difference between interventions was 55.5% (95% CI = 13.9% to 97.1%) in favor of the addition of RTUS feedback. No adverse effects occurred.
RTUS visual feedback increases SA activation in adults with painful shoulders compared with manual facilitation alone.
Determining if RTUS can improve SA muscle activation may help clinicians improve physical therapist interventions for subacromial pain syndrome.
肩峰下疼痛综合征可能会导致前锯肌(SA)激活减少。本研究的目的是确定与单纯手法辅助相比,添加实时超声(RTUS)视觉反馈是否能增加肩部疼痛成人的SA激活。
本评估者盲法、两阶段、随机交叉试验在大学医学影像实验室进行。患有轻至中度单侧肩峰下疼痛的成年人随机接受两种干预措施,且两种干预之间至少有1周的洗脱期。14名参与者被随机分配首先接受RTUS辅助的手法治疗,13名参与者被随机分配首先接受单纯手法治疗。通过RTUS视觉反馈结合手法辅助或单纯手法辅助,对仰卧位“锯肌冲击”进行15次重复。通过表面肌电图测量的SA激活水平被标准化为最大自主等长收缩。
共有25名参与者完成了两种干预措施的完整试验。分析了25个RTUS辅助手法治疗参与者阶段的数据和26个单纯手法治疗参与者阶段的数据。干预措施之间预测的边际平均差异为55.5%(95%CI = 13.9%至97.1%),支持添加RTUS反馈。未出现不良反应。
与单纯手法辅助相比,RTUS视觉反馈可增加肩部疼痛成人的SA激活。
确定RTUS是否能改善SA肌肉激活可能有助于临床医生改进针对肩峰下疼痛综合征的物理治疗干预措施。