Nuffield Department of Primary Care Health Sciences, University of Oxford, Oxford, UK.
Department of Computer Science, Human Centred Computing (HCC), University of Oxford, Oxford, UK.
Fam Pract. 2021 Jun 17;38(3):321-328. doi: 10.1093/fampra/cmaa121.
GPs are encouraged to make brief interventions to support weight loss, but they report concern about these conversations, stating that they need more details on what to say. Knowing how engage in these conversations could encourage GPs to deliver brief interventions for weight loss more frequently.
To examine which specific words and phrases were successful in achieving conversational alignment and minimizing misunderstanding, contributing to effective interventions.
A conversation analysis of English family practice patients participating in a trial of opportunistic weight-management interventions, which incorporated the offer of referral to community weight-management services (CWMS). Qualitative conversation analysis was applied to 246 consultation recordings to identify communication patterns, which contributed to clear, efficient interventions.
Analysis showed variation in how GPs delivered interventions. Some ways of talking created misunderstandings or misalignment, while others avoided these. There were five components of clear and efficient opportunistic weight-management referrals. These were (i) exemplifying CWMS with a recognizable brand name (ii) saying weight-management 'programme' or 'service', rather than 'group' or 'club' (iii) stating that the referral is 'free' early on (iv) saying the number CWMS visits available on referral (v) stating that the CWMS programme available was 'local'.
When making a brief opportunistic intervention to support weight loss, clinicians can follow these five steps to create a smooth and efficient intervention. Knowing this may allay clinicians' fears about these consultations being awkward and improve adherence to guidelines.
鼓励全科医生进行简短干预以支持减肥,但他们对这些对话表示担忧,称他们需要更多关于该说什么的详细信息。了解如何进行这些对话可以鼓励全科医生更频繁地进行简短的减肥干预。
研究哪些特定的单词和短语能够成功实现对话一致,减少误解,从而促进有效的干预。
对参加机会性体重管理干预试验的英国家庭实践患者进行会话分析,该试验纳入了向社区体重管理服务(CWMS)转介的机会。对 246 次咨询记录进行定性会话分析,以识别有助于清晰、高效干预的沟通模式。
分析表明,全科医生实施干预的方式存在差异。有些说话方式会造成误解或不一致,而有些则避免了这些问题。清晰有效的机会性体重管理转介有五个组成部分。这包括 (i) 用可识别的品牌名称举例说明 CWMS (ii) 说体重管理“计划”或“服务”,而不是“小组”或“俱乐部” (iii) 尽早说明转介是“免费”的 (iv) 说明可获得的 CWMS 访问次数 (v) 说明可获得的 CWMS 计划是“本地”的。
当进行简短的机会性干预以支持减肥时,临床医生可以遵循这五个步骤来创建顺畅高效的干预。了解这些内容可能会减轻临床医生对这些咨询感到尴尬的担忧,并提高对指南的遵守。