Center for Dermatology Research, Department of Dermatology, Wake Forest School of Medicine, Winston-Salem, NC Department of Internal Medicine, Vidant Medical Center/East Carolina University, Greenville, NC.
Dermatol Online J. 2020 Nov 15;26(11):13030/qt24d872cs.
Physicians have a fiduciary duty to be honest and to act in the patients' best interest. There are times when these two duties conflict. Honesty is paramount in supporting the physician-patient relationship and loss of patient trust is devastating. Furthermore, even minor deception can suggest a return to the physician authoritarianism of the past century that has been decried by modern ethicists. Nonetheless, circumstances can arise in which good judgement may require less than complete honesty to avoid harm to the patient. If the benefit for the patient is large and the risk from deception is small, thoughtful application of minor deception could be designed to benefit patients. Of course, research is required to fully assess this strategy.
医生有诚信和为患者利益着想的受托责任。但有时这两项义务会发生冲突。诚信是支持医患关系的首要原则,失去患者的信任是毁灭性的。此外,即使是轻微的欺骗也可能让人联想到过去一个世纪被现代伦理学家谴责的医生权威主义。尽管如此,在某些情况下,良好的判断力可能需要不那么完全的诚实,以避免对患者造成伤害。如果对患者的益处很大,而欺骗的风险很小,那么可以慎重考虑使用轻微的欺骗手段来使患者受益。当然,需要进行研究来全面评估这一策略。