Nuvo-Group, Ltd, Tel-Aviv, Israel.
Department of Obstetrics and Gynecology, Perelman School of Medicine, University of Pennsylvania, Philadelphia, PA.
Am J Obstet Gynecol MFM. 2020 May;2(2):100101. doi: 10.1016/j.ajogmf.2020.100101. Epub 2020 Mar 17.
Access to prenatal care can be challenging due to physician shortages and rural geography. The multiple prenatal visits performed to collect basic fetal measurements lead to significant patient burden as well. The standard of care tools for fetal monitoring, external fetal heart rate monitoring with cardiotocography, as used today, must be applied by a medical professional in a healthcare setting. Novel tools to enable a remote and self-administered fetal monitoring solution would significantly alleviate some of the current barriers to care.
To compare maternal and fetal heart rate monitoring data obtained by 'Invu system' (a wireless, wearable, self-administered, fixed-location device containing passive electrical and acoustic sensors) to cardiotocography, toward a true remote fetal monitoring solution.
A prospective, open-label, multicenter study evaluated concurrent use of Invu and cardiotocography in pregnant women, aged 18 to 50 years, with singleton pregnancies ≥32+0 weeks' gestation (NCT03504189). Simultaneous recording sessions from Invu and cardiotocography lasted for ≥30 minutes. Data from the 8 electrical sensors and 4 acoustic sensors in the Invu belt were acquired, digitized, and sent wirelessly for analysis by an algorithm on cloud-based servers. The algorithm validates the data, preprocesses the data to remove noise, detects heartbeats independently from the two data sources (electrical and acoustic), and fuses the detected heartbeat arrays to calculate fetal heart rate (FHR) and maternal heart rate (MHR). The primary performance endpoint was Invu FHR limit of agreement within ± 10 beats per minute (bpm) of FHR measured with cardiotocography.
A total of 147 women were included in the study analysis. The mean (SD) maternal age was 31.8 ±6.9 years, and the mean gestational age was 37.7 ±2.3 weeks. There was a highly significant correlation between FHR measurements from Invu and cardiotocography (r = 0.92; P<0.0001). The 95% limits of agreement for the difference, the range within which most differences between the two measurements will lie, were -8.84 bpm to 8.24 bpm. Invu measurements of MHR were also very similar to cardiotocography and were highly significantly correlated (r = 0.97; P<0.0001). No adverse events were reported during the study.
Although captured by very different methods, the FHR and MHR outputs wirelessly obtained by the Invu system through passive methods were very similar to those obtained by the current standard of care. The limits of agreement for FHR measured by Invu were within a clinically acceptable ± 8 bpm of cardiotocography FHR. The Invu device uses passive technology to allow for safe, non-invasive and convenient monitoring of patients in the clinic and remotely. Further work should investigate how remote perinatal monitoring could best address some of the recent challenges seen with prenatal care and maternal and fetal outcomes.
Registration date: April 20, 2018; First participant enrollment: February 28, 2018; ClinicalTrials.gov registration NCT03504189; https://clinicaltrials.gov/ct2/show/NCT03504189.
由于医生短缺和农村地区的地理条件,获得产前护理可能具有挑战性。为了收集基本的胎儿测量数据,需要多次进行产前检查,这也给患者带来了很大的负担。目前用于胎儿监测的标准工具是外部胎儿心率监测,即胎儿心电图描记术,必须由医疗专业人员在医疗环境中应用。新型工具可以实现远程和自我管理的胎儿监测解决方案,将大大缓解当前护理方面的一些障碍。
将“Invu 系统”(一种无线、可穿戴、自我管理、固定位置的设备,包含无源电和声学传感器)获得的母体和胎儿心率监测数据与胎儿心电图描记术进行比较,以实现真正的远程胎儿监测解决方案。
一项前瞻性、开放标签、多中心研究评估了“Invu 系统”与胎儿心电图描记术在 18 至 50 岁、单胎妊娠≥32+0 周(NCT03504189)的孕妇中的联合使用。Invu 和胎儿心电图描记术的同时记录持续时间≥30 分钟。Invu 腰带中的 8 个电传感器和 4 个声传感器的数据被采集、数字化,并通过云端服务器上的算法无线发送进行分析。该算法验证数据、预处理数据以去除噪声、独立于两个数据源(电和声学)检测心跳,并融合检测到的心跳数组以计算胎儿心率(FHR)和母体心率(MHR)。主要性能终点是 Invu FHR 的差值在±10 次/分钟(bpm)范围内,与胎儿心电图描记术测量的 FHR 一致。
共有 147 名女性纳入研究分析。平均(SD)母亲年龄为 31.8±6.9 岁,平均妊娠周数为 37.7±2.3 周。Invu 和胎儿心电图描记术的 FHR 测量值之间存在高度显著的相关性(r=0.92;P<0.0001)。差值的 95%置信区间,即大多数测量值之间差异所在的范围,为-8.84 bpm 至 8.24 bpm。Invu 测量的 MHR 也与胎儿心电图描记术非常相似,相关性非常显著(r=0.97;P<0.0001)。在研究期间没有报告不良事件。
尽管采用了非常不同的方法,但 Invu 系统通过被动方法无线获取的 FHR 和 MHR 输出与当前标准护理方法获得的输出非常相似。Invu 测量的 FHR 的一致性界限在临床可接受的±8 bpm 范围内与胎儿心电图描记术的 FHR 一致。Invu 设备使用被动技术,可安全、无创、方便地监测诊所和远程患者。进一步的研究应探讨远程围产期监测如何最好地解决最近产前护理和母婴结局方面出现的一些挑战。
注册日期:2018 年 4 月 20 日;第一例参与者入组日期:2018 年 2 月 28 日;临床试验.gov 注册号:NCT03504189;https://clinicaltrials.gov/ct2/show/NCT03504189。