Masters in Medical Education degree programme, Newcastle University, Newcastle upon Tyne, UK.
School of Medical Education, Newcastle University, Newcastle upon Tyne, UK.
Perspect Med Educ. 2021 Jan;10(1):41-49. doi: 10.1007/s40037-020-00636-7. Epub 2020 Dec 23.
Medical career preferences are influenced by a multitude of factors. Currently several specialties are undergoing recruitment problems; we must develop our understanding of medical career decision-making to ensure the production of an appropriate workforce. We aimed to explore the changing career preferences of students during medical school, to better understand this.
This was an interpretivist, qualitative study. Data were collected through semi-structured interviews with seven final-year students to explore why their career preferences had changed during medical school. Transcripts of these interviews were thematically analysed.
Three overarching themes emerged from the analysis: The 'influence of medical school', 'perceived suitability to specialty' and 'belonging and fitting in'. A thematic map captured the participants' perceptions on why their preferences had changed, with major influences echoing existing research. However, novel findings included participants' personalities and enthusiasm changing over time, the need for a 'sense of belonging' and participants defining the term 'variety' uniquely, perceiving their current specialty preference to match their definition.
This was an original, in-depth study on changing career preferences, which is an ill-defined subject within the literature. Analysis revealed preferences changed for a variety of medical school, personal and specialty reasons, leading to the construction of an updated model of medical career decision-making. Medical career preference remains a dynamic and ever-evolving phenomenon, influenced by an intricate interplay of internal and external factors. An understanding of this is crucial for future workforce planning.
医学职业偏好受多种因素影响。目前,一些专业领域正面临招聘难题;我们必须深入了解医学职业决策,以确保培养出合适的劳动力。我们旨在探讨医学生在医学院期间职业偏好的变化,以更好地理解这一点。
这是一项解释主义的定性研究。通过对 7 名即将毕业的学生进行半结构化访谈来收集数据,以探讨他们在医学院期间职业偏好发生变化的原因。对这些访谈的记录进行了主题分析。
分析产生了三个总体主题:“医学院的影响”、“对专业的感知适合性”和“归属感和适应感”。一个主题图捕捉到了参与者对偏好变化原因的看法,主要影响因素与现有研究相呼应。然而,新的发现包括参与者的个性和热情随时间的变化、对归属感的需求以及参与者对“多样性”的独特定义,认为他们目前的专业偏好符合他们的定义。
这是一项关于职业偏好变化的原创、深入研究,这在文献中是一个定义不明确的主题。分析表明,职业偏好的变化有多种医学院、个人和专业原因,导致对医学职业决策的更新模型的构建。医学职业偏好仍然是一个动态的、不断发展的现象,受到内部和外部因素的复杂相互作用的影响。了解这一点对于未来的劳动力规划至关重要。