Faculty of Dentistry, Department of Restorative Dentistry, Universiti Kebangsaan Malaysia, Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia.
Faculty of Dentisty, Department of Restorative Dentistry, Universiti Kebangsaan Malaysia, Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia.
Eur J Dent Educ. 2021 Nov;25(4):744-752. doi: 10.1111/eje.12653. Epub 2021 Jan 7.
The application of video-based learning in dentistry has been widely investigated; however, the nature of on-screen video enhancements of the video has been minimally explored in the literature. This study investigated the effectiveness of an in-class and on-demand enhanced video to support learning on removable partial dentures in terms of knowledge acquisition, perception and clinical skill performance.
Fifty-four dental students enrolled in 2018 were recruited as participants and assigned to two groups. Both groups were given the same lecture and asked to watch the same video in either the enhanced or non-enhanced version. The enhanced video was modified with the contemporaneous subtitle of the presenters' dialogue, text bullet points and summary text pages. The knowledge acquisition from the two types of video was subjected to pre- and post-tests one month after the students watched the video. A questionnaire was used to evaluate the students' perceptions of the learning experience and a performance test on practical skills was performed after six weeks. All the students responded to the test (100%).
The enhanced video demonstration improved the students' short-term knowledge acquisition after they watched the video, with an average score of 1.59 points higher in the enhanced group than in the non-enhanced group (p < .05). The practical performance did not differ between the two groups. The students were more likely accepted the enhanced video as a replacement of the existing teaching method rather than a teaching supplement (70.3%).
The application of the enhanced video demonstration resulted in a better theoretical knowledge retention but not practical performance. Students also preferred watching video to using conventional learning methods.
视频教学在牙科领域的应用已得到广泛研究;然而,文献中对屏幕上视频增强的性质的研究甚少。本研究旨在调查课堂内和按需增强视频在可摘局部义齿学习方面的有效性,包括知识获取、感知和临床技能表现。
2018 年,54 名牙科学生被招募为参与者,并被分为两组。两组学生都接受了相同的讲座,并观看了增强版或非增强版的相同视频。增强版视频对演示者对话的同期字幕、文本要点和总结页面进行了修改。在观看视频一个月后,对两种类型视频的知识获取进行了预测试和后测试。问卷调查评估学生对学习体验的看法,六周后进行实际技能表现测试。所有学生均对测试做出了回应(100%)。
增强视频演示提高了学生观看视频后的短期知识获取,增强组的平均得分比非增强组高 1.59 分(p<0.05)。两组学生的实际操作表现无差异。学生更倾向于将增强视频作为现有教学方法的替代,而不是教学补充(70.3%)。
增强视频演示应用提高了理论知识的保留,但对实际操作表现没有影响。学生也更喜欢观看视频而不是使用传统的学习方法。