Department of Removable Prosthodontics, Faculty of Dentistry, Tehran University of Medical Sciences, Quds Street, Tehran, Iran.
J Dent Educ. 2012 Mar;76(3):354-9.
Dental students in programs around the world typically pass preclinical courses before entering the clinic and working on actual patients. Since fixed prosthodontics is a preclinical course that requires a great deal of effort, students may experience a substantial amount of stress that may affect their self-confidence and/or clinical performance. In this study, an instructional video CD (VCD) and study guide depicting the step-by-step procedures involved in a metal-ceramic tooth preparation and provisional crown fabrication was prepared. Students at the Faculty of Dentistry, Tehran University of Medical Sciences, Tehran, Iran, were divided randomly into two groups. Group A students trained as usual with live patients, and Group B students were given a copy of the VCD and study guide following a lecture. The students in Group B were encouraged to read the study guide and watch the VCD after live demonstrations. Then, both groups practiced individually on mannequins. At the end of the course, the students completed a sixteen-item questionnaire about their stress level, self-confidence, and knowledge base. The results showed that the students exposed to the extra media performed significantly better on some practical phases, e.g., laboratory procedures. A moderate, insignificant correlation was detected between exposure to media and decreasing the students' stress and self-esteem. We concluded that supplementary teaching aids such as a VCD and study guide may improve the clinical performance of dental students to some extent, but the live demonstration is still preferred by students.
世界各地的牙科专业学生在进入临床阶段并为实际患者治疗之前,通常需要先通过临床前课程。由于固定修复学是一门需要大量努力的临床前课程,学生可能会经历大量的压力,这可能会影响他们的自信和/或临床表现。在这项研究中,我们制作了一张教学视频光盘(VCD)和学习指南,描绘了金属陶瓷牙预备和临时冠制作的逐步过程。伊朗德黑兰医科大学牙科学院的学生被随机分为两组。A 组学生像往常一样在真实患者身上接受培训,B 组学生在讲座后收到了 VCD 和学习指南的副本。我们鼓励 B 组学生在现场演示后阅读学习指南并观看 VCD。然后,两组学生都在模型上进行单独练习。课程结束时,学生们完成了一份关于他们的压力水平、自信和知识库的十六项问卷调查。结果表明,接触额外媒体的学生在一些实践阶段,例如实验室操作,表现明显更好。我们发现,接触媒体与减轻学生的压力和自尊心之间存在中度但无统计学意义的相关性。我们的结论是,补充教学辅助工具,如 VCD 和学习指南,可以在一定程度上提高牙科学生的临床表现,但学生仍然更喜欢现场演示。