Caroccia Francesco, Moscagiuri Francesco, Falconio Luigi, Festa Felice, D'Attilio Michele
Department of Medical, Oral and Biotechnological Sciences, University of Chieti-Pescara, 66100 Chieti, Italy.
J Clin Med. 2020 Dec 24;10(1):33. doi: 10.3390/jcm10010033.
We aimed to report an update of the systematic review by Petrén et al. (2003). The objective was to evaluate how orthodontic treatments can affect unilateral posterior crossbite (UPXB) in primary and early mixed dentition. Several databases were consulted, and articles published between January 2002 and March 2020 were selected. This review examines the following studies: randomized clinical trials, prospective and retrospective studies with concurrent untreated or normal control groups, and clinical trials comparing at least two treatment strategies. Among the 1581 articles retrieved from the searches, 11 studies were included. Quad-helix (QH) and expansion plate (EP) appliances were compared in three studies. One study compared rapid maxillary expansion (RME) treatment anchored on primary dentition otherwise on permanent molars. One study compared RME and a modified RME with arms extended until deciduous canine and EP. Four studies evaluated the effects of expansion appliances compared with a control group. Compared with the previous review, the quality of the included studies is higher. However, heterogeneity of treatments, different strategies in measurements, lack of a similar follow-up length, and absence of a cost-effectiveness analysis preclude the possibility of providing reliable scientific evidence on the most effective UPXB treatment in primary and early mixed dentition.
我们旨在报告Petrén等人(2003年)系统评价的更新情况。目的是评估正畸治疗如何影响乳牙列和早期混合牙列中的单侧后牙反合(UPXB)。我们查阅了多个数据库,并选取了2002年1月至2020年3月发表的文章。本综述审查了以下研究:随机临床试验、设有同期未治疗或正常对照组的前瞻性和回顾性研究,以及比较至少两种治疗策略的临床试验。在检索到的1581篇文章中,纳入了11项研究。三项研究比较了四螺旋(QH)矫治器和扩弓板(EP)矫治器。一项研究比较了以乳牙列或恒牙磨牙为支抗的快速上颌扩弓(RME)治疗。一项研究比较了RME和改良RME,改良RME的臂延长至乳尖牙和EP。四项研究评估了扩弓矫治器与对照组相比的效果。与之前的综述相比,纳入研究的质量更高。然而,治疗方法的异质性、测量方法的不同、随访时间长度不一致以及缺乏成本效益分析,使得无法就乳牙列和早期混合牙列中最有效的UPXB治疗提供可靠的科学证据。