Harvard Humanitarian Initiative, Harvard University, Cambridge, Massachusetts, United States of America.
Division of Global Emergency Medicine and Humanitarian Programs, Department of Emergency Medicine, Harvard Medical School, Brigham and Women's Hospital, Boston, Massachusetts, United States of America.
PLoS One. 2020 Dec 30;15(12):e0244185. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0244185. eCollection 2020.
Pastoralism is widely practiced in arid lands and is the primary means of livelihood for approximately 268 million people across Africa. Environmental, interpersonal, and transactional variables such as vegetation and water availability, conflict, ethnic tensions, and private/public land delineation influence the movements of these populations. The challenges of climate change and conflict are widely felt by nomadic pastoralists in Somalia, where resources are scarce, natural disasters are increasingly common, and protracted conflict has plagued communities for decades. Bereft of real-time data, researchers and programmatic personnel often turn to post hoc analysis to understand the interaction between climate, conflict, and migration, and design programs to address the needs of nomadic pastoralists. By designing an Agent-Based Model to simulate the movement of nomadic pastoralists based on typologically-diverse, historical data of environmental, interpersonal, and transactional variables in Somaliland and Puntland between 2008 and 2018, this study explores how pastoralists respond to changing environments. Through subsequent application of spatial analysis such as choropleth maps, kernel density mapping, and standard deviational ellipses, we characterize the resultant pastoralist population distribution in response to these variables. Outcomes demonstrate a large scale spatio-temporal trend of pastoralists migrating to the southeast of the study area with high density areas in the south of Nugaal, the northwest of Sool, and along the Ethiopian border. While minimal inter-seasonal variability is seen, multiple analyses support the consolidation of pastoralists to specifically favorable regions. Exploration of the large-scale population, climate, and conflict trends allows for cogent narratives and associative hypotheses regarding the pastoralist migration during the study period. While this model produces compelling associations between pastoralist movements and terrestrial and conflict variables, it relies heavily on assumptions and incomplete data that are not necessarily representative of realities on the ground. Given the paucity of data regarding pastoralist decision-making and migration, validation remains challenging.
畜牧业在干旱地区广泛存在,是非洲约 2.68 亿人民的主要生计方式。环境、人际和交易变量,如植被和水的可用性、冲突、种族紧张局势以及公私土地的划分,影响着这些人口的流动。气候变化和冲突的挑战在索马里的游牧牧民中广泛感受到,那里资源匮乏,自然灾害越来越频繁,旷日持久的冲突困扰着社区几十年。由于缺乏实时数据,研究人员和计划人员经常诉诸事后分析来了解气候、冲突和移民之间的相互作用,并设计方案来满足游牧牧民的需求。通过设计一个基于代理的模型,根据 2008 年至 2018 年在索马里兰和邦特兰的环境、人际和交易变量的多种类型的历史数据来模拟游牧牧民的移动,本研究探讨了牧民如何应对不断变化的环境。通过随后应用空间分析,如等值线图、核密度映射和标准离差椭圆,我们描述了对这些变量的牧民人口分布的响应。结果表明,牧民大规模的时空趋势是向研究区域的东南方向迁移,在努加尔的南部、苏勒的西北部和与埃塞俄比亚边界沿线有高密度区域。虽然季节性变化很小,但多项分析支持牧民向特定有利地区的整合。对大规模人口、气候和冲突趋势的探索,使得对研究期间牧民迁移的合理叙述和关联假设成为可能。虽然该模型在牧民运动与陆地和冲突变量之间产生了引人注目的关联,但它严重依赖于假设和不完整的数据,这些数据不一定能代表实际情况。鉴于有关牧民决策和迁移的数据匮乏,验证仍然具有挑战性。