Department of Health Outcomes and Behavior, Moffitt Cancer Center, Tampa, FL, United States.
Department of Oncologic Sciences, University of South Florida, Tampa, FL, United States.
JMIR Mhealth Uhealth. 2020 Dec 31;8(12):e21643. doi: 10.2196/21643.
The recent widespread availability of augmented reality via smartphone offers an opportunity to translate cue exposure therapy for smoking cessation from the laboratory to the real world. Despite significant reductions in the smoking rates in the last decade, approximately 13.7% of the adults in the United States continue to smoke. Smoking-related cue exposure has demonstrated promise as an adjuvant therapy in the laboratory, but practical limitations have prevented its success in the real world. Augmented reality technology presents an innovative approach to overcome these limitations.
The aim of this study was to develop a smartphone app that presents smoking-related augmented reality images for cue exposure. Smokers provided feedback on the images and reported on the perceived urge to smoke, qualities of reality/coexistence, and general feedback about quality and functioning. The feedback was used to refine the augmented reality images within the app.
In collaboration with an augmented reality design company, we developed 6 smoking-related images (cigarette, lighter, ashtray, lit cigarette in ashtray, etc) and 6 neutral images similar in size or complexity for comparison (pen, eraser, notebook, soda bottle with droplets, etc). Ten smokers completed a survey of demographic characteristics, smoking history and behavior, dependence on nicotine, motivation to quit smoking, and familiarity with augmented reality technology. Then, participants viewed each augmented reality image and provided ratings on 10-point Likert scales for urge to smoke and reality/coexistence of the image into the scene. Participants were also queried with open-ended questions regarding the features of the images.
Of the 10 participants, 5 (50%) had experienced augmented reality prior to the laboratory visit, but only 4 of those 5 participants used augmented reality at least weekly. Although the sample was small (N=10), smokers reported significantly higher urge to smoke after viewing the smoking-related augmented reality images (median 4.58, SD 3.49) versus the neutral images (median 1.42, SD 3.01) (Z=-2.14, P=.03; d=0.70). The average reality and coexistence ratings of the images did not differ between smoking-related and neutral images (all P>.29). Augmented reality images were found on average to be realistic (mean [SD] score 6.49 [3.11]) and have good environmental coexistence (mean [SD] score 6.93 [3.04]) and user coexistence (mean [SD] score 6.38 [3.27]) on the 10-point scale. Participant interviews revealed some areas of excellence (eg, details of the lit cigarette) and areas for improvement (eg, stability of images, lighting).
All images were generally perceived as being realistic and well-integrated into the environment. However, the smoking augmented reality images produced higher urge to smoke than the neutral augmented reality images. In total, our findings support the potential utility of augmented reality for cue exposure therapy. Future directions and next steps are discussed.
最近智能手机上广泛提供的增强现实技术为将戒烟的线索暴露疗法从实验室转移到现实世界提供了机会。尽管在过去十年中吸烟率显著下降,但美国仍有约 13.7%的成年人吸烟。与吸烟相关的线索暴露已被证明是实验室辅助治疗的一种有希望的方法,但实际限制使其无法在现实世界中取得成功。增强现实技术提供了一种创新的方法来克服这些限制。
本研究旨在开发一款可提供吸烟相关增强现实图像进行线索暴露的智能手机应用程序。吸烟者对图像提供反馈,并报告吸烟的冲动感、现实/共存的质量以及对质量和功能的一般反馈。根据反馈信息,对应用程序中的增强现实图像进行了改进。
我们与一家增强现实设计公司合作,开发了 6 个与吸烟相关的图像(香烟、打火机、烟灰缸、点燃的香烟在烟灰缸中等)和 6 个相似大小或复杂度的中性图像(笔、橡皮擦、笔记本、带水滴的苏打水瓶等)进行比较。10 名吸烟者完成了一份关于人口统计学特征、吸烟史和行为、尼古丁依赖、戒烟动机以及对增强现实技术熟悉程度的调查。然后,参与者观看每个增强现实图像,并对吸烟相关的增强现实图像和图像进入场景的现实/共存感进行 10 点李克特量表评分。参与者还被问到关于图像特征的开放式问题。
在 10 名参与者中,有 5 名(50%)在实验室访问之前已经体验过增强现实,但其中只有 4 名参与者每周至少使用增强现实一次。尽管样本量较小(N=10),但吸烟者在观看吸烟相关的增强现实图像后报告的吸烟冲动明显更高(中位数 4.58,SD 3.49),而中性图像(中位数 1.42,SD 3.01)(Z=-2.14,P=.03;d=0.70)。吸烟相关图像和中性图像的图像现实感和共存感评分没有差异(均 P>.29)。增强现实图像的平均现实感(平均[SD]评分 6.49 [3.11])和良好的环境共存感(平均[SD]评分 6.93 [3.04])和用户共存感(平均[SD]评分 6.38 [3.27])在 10 点量表上都很高。参与者访谈揭示了一些优点(例如,点燃香烟的细节)和改进的领域(例如,图像稳定性、照明)。
所有图像总体上被认为是现实的,并且与环境很好地融合在一起。然而,吸烟的增强现实图像比中性的增强现实图像产生了更高的吸烟冲动。总的来说,我们的发现支持增强现实技术在线索暴露治疗中的潜在应用。讨论了未来的方向和下一步措施。