Hsiao Chih-Yang, Teng Xiao, Su Tung-Hung, Lee Po-Huang, Kao Jia-Horng, Huang Kai-Wen
Graduate Institute of Clinical Medicine, National Taiwan University College of Medicine, Taipei.
Department of Surgery, National Taiwan University Hospital, Taipei.
Quant Imaging Med Surg. 2021 Jan;11(1):351-361. doi: 10.21037/qims-20-394.
Second harmonic generation (SHG)/two-photon excited fluorescence (TPEF) microscopy is commonly used for the quantitative assessment of liver fibrosis; however, the accuracy is susceptible to sampling error and count error due to disturbances induced by some forms of collagen in liver specimens. In this study, we sought to improve the accuracy of quantitative assessments by removing the effects of this disturbing collagen and optimizing the sampling protocol.
Large liver resection samples from 111 patients with chronic hepatitis B were scanned using SHG/TPEF microscopy with multiple adjacent images. During the quantitative assessment, we then removed SHG signals associated with three types of extraneous physiological collagen: large patches of collagen near the boundary of the capsule, collagen around tubular structures, and collagen associated with distorted vessel walls. The optimal sampling protocol was identified by comparing scans from regions of interest of various sizes (3×3 tiles and 5×5 tiles) with full scans of the same tissue.
The proposed auto-correction algorithm detected 88 of 97 (90.7%) disturbing collagen on the images from the validation set. Removing these signals of disturbing collagen improved the correlation between Metavir stage and quantification of all 41 proposed collagen features. Through optimal sampling, five scans of 5×5 tiles or ten scans of 3×3 tiles were sufficient to minimize the mean error rate to around 2% of collagen percentage quantification and to achieve similar correlations around 0.27 with Metavir stage as using full tissue scans.
Our results demonstrate that the quantitative assessments of liver fibrosis can be greatly enhanced in terms of accuracy and efficiency through optimal sampling and the automated removal of disturbing collagen signals. These types of image processing could be integrated in next-generation SHG/TPEF microscopic systems.
二次谐波产生(SHG)/双光子激发荧光(TPEF)显微镜常用于肝纤维化的定量评估;然而,由于肝脏标本中某些形式的胶原蛋白引起的干扰,其准确性易受采样误差和计数误差的影响。在本研究中,我们试图通过消除这种干扰性胶原蛋白的影响并优化采样方案来提高定量评估的准确性。
使用SHG/TPEF显微镜对111例慢性乙型肝炎患者的大肝切除样本进行扫描,获取多个相邻图像。在定量评估过程中,我们去除了与三种类型的无关生理胶原蛋白相关的SHG信号:包膜边界附近的大片胶原蛋白、管状结构周围的胶原蛋白以及与扭曲血管壁相关的胶原蛋白。通过比较不同大小感兴趣区域(3×3块和5×5块)的扫描结果与同一组织的全扫描结果,确定了最佳采样方案。
所提出的自动校正算法在验证集图像上检测出97个干扰性胶原蛋白中的88个(90.7%)。去除这些干扰性胶原蛋白信号改善了Metavir分期与所有41种提出的胶原蛋白特征定量之间的相关性。通过优化采样,五次5×5块的扫描或十次3×3块的扫描足以将平均误差率最小化至胶原蛋白百分比定量的约2%,并实现与使用全组织扫描时与Metavir分期相似的约0.27的相关性。
我们的结果表明,通过优化采样和自动去除干扰性胶原蛋白信号,肝纤维化的定量评估在准确性和效率方面可以得到极大提高。这些类型的图像处理可以集成到下一代SHG/TPEF显微系统中。