Department of Pediatrics, Hemophilia & Thrombosis Center, University of Colorado and Childrens Hospital Colorado, Aurora, CO, USA.
Departments of Medicine and Pediatrics, Hemophilia & Thrombosis Center, University of Colorado and UCHealth, Aurora, CO, USA.
Haemophilia. 2021 Feb;27 Suppl 3:87-95. doi: 10.1111/hae.14099. Epub 2021 Jan 4.
Options for management of haemophilia are increasing rapidly with completely novel therapeutic approaches that cannot be compared using traditional factor assays. In addition, as prophylaxis regimens have improved, bleeding rates have decreased, and consequently, it is difficult to show an impact of novel therapies on rates of spontaneous bleeding. There is currently an urgent need for a panel of outcome measures to compare therapies that are dissimilar in many essential ways. Conventional objective outcome measures including joint physical examination and joint imaging continue to hold a central importance. Factor assays are essential for evaluation of products derived from native factor genes, but are not applicable to some extended half-life factors or non-factor bypassing agents. Global assays including thrombin generation and chromogenic assays of factor X activation are under investigation for their usefulness in haemophilia assessment. Bleeding rate is a conventional subjective patient-reported outcome that, while decreasing in frequency, is indispensable as an outcome given that the primary manifestation of haemophilia is bleeding. Other patient-reported outcomes such as pain intensity and interference, health-related quality of life and activities and participation are increasingly important to distinguish superior outcomes in comparative trials. This review of outcome measures for haemophilia presents examples of existing outcome measures with an emphasis on their strengths and limitations.
血友病的治疗选择正在迅速增加,出现了许多无法用传统因子检测方法进行比较的全新治疗方法。此外,随着预防治疗方案的改进,出血率有所下降,因此,很难表明新型疗法对自发性出血率有影响。目前迫切需要一组疗效指标来比较在许多重要方面存在差异的治疗方法。传统的客观疗效指标,包括关节体格检查和关节影像学检查,仍然具有重要意义。因子检测对于评估来源于天然因子基因的产品是必不可少的,但不适用于某些半衰期延长的因子或非因子旁路制剂。包括凝血酶生成和因子 X 激活显色检测在内的全球检测方法,正在被研究用于评估血友病的有效性。出血率是一种传统的主观患者报告结局,尽管其发生频率正在下降,但由于血友病的主要表现是出血,因此作为一种结局指标仍然不可或缺。其他患者报告结局,如疼痛强度和干扰、健康相关生活质量以及活动和参与,在比较试验中对于区分更好的结局变得越来越重要。本文回顾了血友病的疗效指标,介绍了现有的疗效指标,并重点介绍了它们的优缺点。