Dolgov Nikolay, Dikova Tsanka
Pisarenko Institute for Problems of Strength, Nat. Ac. Sci. of Ukraine, Timiryazevska Str, Kyiv, 01014, Ukraine; National Transport University, 1 Omelianovycha-Pavlenka Str, Kyiv, 01010, Ukraine.
Faculty of Dental Medicine, Medical University of Varna, 84 Tsar Osvoboditel Blvd, Varna, 9000, Bulgaria.
J Mech Behav Biomed Mater. 2021 Mar;115:104297. doi: 10.1016/j.jmbbm.2020.104297. Epub 2020 Dec 29.
The aim of the present paper is to use analytical methodology by 2D shear-lag model in parametric analysis of the normal stress in the coating. The tension of a substrate with coatings on its top and bottom surfaces is considered. The parametric study is performed by varying coating thickness and elastic properties both the coating and the substrate. The calculations are done for different groups of dental materials - polyetheretherketone, dental resin composite and porcelain as a coating material and high gold, palladium and Co-Cr alloys as a substrate material. It is established that the coating thickness strongly influences the normal stresses parallel to the loading axis - its increasing leads to decreasing of normal stresses in the coating. However, the increase of the coating thickness results in negligible increase of the additional normal stresses (perpendicular to the loading axis) in the central part of the coating. Young's modulus of the coating considerably influences the normal stresses parallel to the loading axis, while its influence on the additional normal stresses appears mainly in the zones near the free edge of the coating. The increase of the modulus of elasticity of the coating causes increase of the both normal stresses. The increasing of Young's modulus of the substrate insignificantly influences on the both normal stress in the coating. It is found that: 1) the lowest normal stresses are generated in the porcelain layer with the largest thickness of 2.0 mm; 2) the porcelain is characterized with the highest normal stresses compared to the polymer and composite coating materials; 3) the alloy type of the substrate has negligible effect on both the normal stress in the porcelain coating. The results are validated by tensile test of Co-Cr dental alloy specimens coated with porcelain. A good agreement is found between the analytical approach and the failure behaviour of the porcelain coating. Therefore, the proposed analytical model can be used as a tool to study the stress state in the coating under tensile test of coated flat specimens.
本文的目的是使用二维剪滞模型的分析方法对涂层中的正应力进行参数分析。考虑了顶部和底部表面带有涂层的基体的拉伸情况。通过改变涂层厚度以及涂层和基体的弹性特性进行参数研究。针对不同组别的牙科材料进行了计算——聚醚醚酮、牙科树脂复合材料和作为涂层材料的陶瓷,以及作为基体材料的高金、钯和钴铬合金。结果表明,涂层厚度对平行于加载轴的正应力有强烈影响——涂层厚度增加会导致涂层中正应力减小。然而,涂层厚度的增加会导致涂层中部垂直于加载轴的附加正应力增加幅度可忽略不计。涂层的杨氏模量对平行于加载轴的正应力有显著影响,而其对附加正应力的影响主要出现在涂层自由边缘附近的区域。涂层弹性模量的增加会导致两种正应力都增加。基体杨氏模量的增加对涂层中的两种正应力影响不显著。研究发现:1)厚度为2.0毫米的陶瓷层产生的正应力最低;2)与聚合物和复合涂层材料相比,陶瓷的正应力最高;3)基体的合金类型对陶瓷涂层中的正应力影响可忽略不计。通过对涂有陶瓷的钴铬牙科合金试样进行拉伸试验验证了结果。在分析方法与陶瓷涂层的失效行为之间发现了良好的一致性。因此,所提出的分析模型可作为研究涂层平板试样拉伸试验下涂层应力状态的工具。