Time-temperature analyses of cell killing of synchronous G1 and S phase Chinese hamster cells in vitro.

Time-temperature analyses of durations of heating required to achieve isosurvival were used to compare hyperthermic cell killing of synchronous Chinese hamster ovary (CHO) cells heated in G1 or S at temperatures of 42 to 45.5 degrees C. G1 populations were obtained by incubation of mitotic cells for 90 min at 37 degrees C. S phase populations were obtained by incubation of mitotic cells for 12 h at 37 degrees C in medium supplemented with 2 micrograms/ml aphidicolin, a reversible inhibitor of DNA alpha polymerase; S phase survival was also determined in an aphidicolin-free system by using high specific activity [3H]thymidine. In both systems, the thermosensitivity was similar and decreased as the cells progressed from early S phase, in agreement with earlier studies (R. A. Read, M. H. Fox, and J. S. Bedford. Radiat. Res. 98, 491-505 (1984]. A comparison of Arrhenius plots of the inverse of durations of heating required to achieve isosurvival for cells heated in G1 or S phase showed similar temperature dependence above 43.5 degrees C, yet the plots for heat-sensitive S phase cells were offset from those for heat-resistant G1 cells by about 1.5 degrees C, i.e., S phase cells respond to 43 degrees C with a rate similar to that observed in G1 cells heated at 44.5 degrees C. Using least-squares regression of the semilog plots, the curves were analyzed either as continually bending curves or as two straight lines with a break at 43.5 degrees C. When the data were analyzed using two straight lines, no significant differences in the slopes of the time-temperature plots of G1 or S phase cells were observed. A quantitative comparison between the two methods of data analysis demonstrated that in both phases the data were better fit with a continuously curving line, rather than two straight lines.