Abolvardi Masoud, Akhlaghian Marzieh, Hamidi Shishvan Hadi, Dastan Farivar
Department of Oral and Maxillofacial Radiology, Faculty of Dentistry, AJA University of Medical Sciences, Tehran, Iran.
Department of Prosthodontics, School of Dentistry, Shiraz University of Medical Sciences, Shiraz, Iran.
Imaging Sci Dent. 2020 Dec;50(4):291-298. doi: 10.5624/isd.2020.50.4.291. Epub 2020 Dec 15.
The detection and exact localization of penetrating foreign bodies are crucial for the appropriate management of patients with dentoalveolar trauma. This study compared the efficacy of cone-beam computed tomography (CBCT) and spiral computed tomography (CT) scans for the detection of different foreign bodies composed of 5 frequently encountered materials in 2 sizes. The effect of the location of the foreign bodies on their visibility was also analyzed.
In this in vitro study, metal, tooth, stone, glass, and plastic particles measuring 1×1×1 mm and 2×2×2 mm were prepared. They were implanted in a sheep's head in the tongue muscle, nasal cavity, and at the interface of the mandibular cortex and soft tissue. CBCT and spiral CT scans were taken and the visibility of foreign bodies was scored by 4 skilled maxillofacial radiologists who were blinded to the location and number of foreign bodies.
CT and CBCT were equally accurate in visualizing metal, stone, and tooth particles of both sizes. However, CBCT was better for detecting glass particles in the periosteum. Although both imaging modalities visualized plastic particles poorly, CT was slightly better for detecting plastic particles, especially the smaller ones.
Considering the lower patient radiation dose and cost, CBCT can be used with almost equal accuracy as CT for detecting foreign bodies of different compositions and sizes in multiple maxillofacial regions. However, CT performed better for detecting plastic particles.
对于牙牙槽创伤患者的恰当治疗而言,穿透性异物的检测及精确定位至关重要。本研究比较了锥形束计算机断层扫描(CBCT)和螺旋计算机断层扫描(CT)在检测由5种常见材料制成的2种尺寸不同异物方面的效能。还分析了异物位置对其可视性的影响。
在这项体外研究中,制备了尺寸为1×1×1毫米和2×2×2毫米的金属、牙齿、石头、玻璃和塑料颗粒。将它们植入羊头的舌肌、鼻腔以及下颌骨皮质与软组织的界面处。进行了CBCT和螺旋CT扫描,由4名对异物位置和数量不知情的熟练颌面放射科医生对异物的可视性进行评分。
CT和CBCT在显示两种尺寸的金属、石头和牙齿颗粒方面同样准确。然而,CBCT在检测骨膜中的玻璃颗粒方面表现更佳。尽管两种成像方式对塑料颗粒的显示都不佳,但CT在检测塑料颗粒方面稍好,尤其是较小的塑料颗粒。
考虑到患者辐射剂量较低和成本因素,CBCT在检测多个颌面区域中不同成分和尺寸的异物时,其准确性几乎与CT相当。然而,CT在检测塑料颗粒方面表现更佳。