Clausen Hanne, Ruud Torleif, Odden Sigrun, Benth Jūratė Šaltytė, Heiervang Kristin Sverdvik, Stuen Hanne Kilen, Landheim Anne
Department of Research and Development, Division of Mental Health Services, Akerhus University Hospital, Lørenskog, Norway.
Norwegian National Advisory Unit on Concurrent Substance Abuse and Mental Health Disorders, Innlandet Hospital Trust, Brumunddal, Norway.
Front Psychiatry. 2020 Dec 23;11:607071. doi: 10.3389/fpsyt.2020.607071. eCollection 2020.
Persons with severe mental illness often face difficulties in accessing and receiving adequate services enabling them to live independently. Many have co-occurring substance use problems that increase the risk of adverse outcomes. Community-based service models have been implemented around the world, including assertive community treatment (ACT), but the knowledge of rehabilitation outcomes in different subgroups is limited. We aimed to explore rehabilitation outcomes among patients suffering severe mental illness with and without substance use problems who had received ACT services for at least 2 years. Additionally, we compared differences in changes between the two groups. A total of 142 patients who received services for 2 years from the first 12 Norwegian ACT teams were included. Eighty-four (59%) had problematic substance use, while 58 (41%) did not. Data regarding housing, activity, symptoms, functioning, and subjective quality of life were collected upon enrollment into ACT and at 2 years of follow-up. Clinician-rated scales and self-report questionnaires were used. Changes within the two groups and differences in change between the groups were assessed using generalized linear mixed models. Both groups were more likely to have good housing, higher level of functioning, and less anxiety and depressive symptoms after 2 years. The odds of good housing among participants with problematic substance use increased only after adjusting for age and gender. Participants with problematic substance use had less severe symptoms, particularly negative and manic symptoms, while participants without problematic substance use reported improved satisfaction with life in general. Neither group experienced a change in having a meaningful daily activity, positive symptoms, practical and social functioning, or subjective quality of life. The reduction of manic symptoms in the substance use group was the only difference between the groups. After 2 years, patients with and without problematic substance use experienced improvements in several important domains. Furthermore, the improvements were similar in both groups for most outcomes. This may suggest that ACT has a place in the continued effort toward integrated and comprehensive community services empowering patients with severe mental illness to achieve and sustain an independent life, including marginalized groups with severe substance use.
患有严重精神疾病的人在获得和接受足够的服务以实现独立生活方面常常面临困难。许多人同时存在物质使用问题,这增加了不良后果的风险。包括积极社区治疗(ACT)在内的基于社区的服务模式已在全球实施,但不同亚组康复结果的相关知识有限。我们旨在探讨接受ACT服务至少2年的、有或无物质使用问题的严重精神疾病患者的康复结果。此外,我们比较了两组之间变化的差异。纳入了来自挪威最初12个ACT团队且接受服务达2年的142名患者。其中84人(59%)存在物质使用问题,而58人(41%)没有。在加入ACT时以及随访2年时收集了有关住房、活动、症状、功能和主观生活质量的数据。使用了临床医生评定量表和自我报告问卷。使用广义线性混合模型评估两组内的变化以及组间变化的差异。两组在2年后都更有可能拥有良好的住房、更高的功能水平以及更少的焦虑和抑郁症状。存在物质使用问题的参与者中,在调整年龄和性别后,拥有良好住房的几率才增加。存在物质使用问题的参与者症状较轻,尤其是阴性和躁狂症状,而无物质使用问题的参与者总体上对生活的满意度有所提高。两组在有意义的日常活动、阳性症状、实际和社交功能或主观生活质量方面均未出现变化。物质使用组躁狂症状的减轻是两组之间唯一的差异。2年后,有或无物质使用问题的患者在几个重要领域都有改善。此外,大多数结果在两组中的改善情况相似。这可能表明,在持续努力提供综合全面的社区服务、使患有严重精神疾病的患者能够实现并维持独立生活(包括有严重物质使用问题的边缘化群体)方面,ACT有其作用。