Monrad E S, Hess O M, Murakami T, Nonogi H, Corin W J, Krayenbuehl H P
Division of Cardiology, University Hospital, Zurich, Switzerland.
Circulation. 1988 Mar;77(3):613-24. doi: 10.1161/01.cir.77.3.613.
We studied the hemodynamic response to supine bicycle exercise in 20 patients late (10 +/- 2 years) after aortic valve replacement (for aortic stenosis in 12 patients, aortic insufficiency in six patients, and for combined stenosis and insufficiency in two patients). The pulmonary artery wedge pressure was obtained with a pulmonary artery balloon catheter, and left ventriculography was performed by digital-subtraction angiography after injection of radiographic contrast into the pulmonary artery. These patients were compared with 11 control subjects with no or minimal cardiac disease studied routinely for evaluation of chest pain in whom left ventricular end-diastolic pressure and a direct contrast ventriculogram were obtained. Compared with the control population, the study population had similar left heart filling pressures (7 +/- 3 vs 9 +/- 3 mm Hg, NS), but higher left ventricular ejection fractions (75 +/- 7% vs 67 +/- 7%, p less than .02) and higher left ventricular muscle mass indexes (106 +/- 28 vs 85 +/- 9 g/m2, p less than .01). Elevated myocardial muscle mass led to lower systolic wall stress in the study population than in the control subjects (254 +/- 65 vs 320 +/- 49 10(3).dynes/cm2, p less than .01) and might explain the higher ejection fraction observed. Fourteen patients had a normal response to exercise (with left heart filling pressures of 16 +/- 4 vs 18 +/- 2 mm Hg for control subjects, NS; and left ventricular ejection fraction of 77 +/- 8% vs 73 +/- 5% for control subjects, NS). However, while the remaining six patients had a normal exercise left ventricular ejection fraction (72 +/- 9%, NS), they had an abnormal rise in left heart filling pressure (33 +/- 8 mm Hg, p less than .01). Preoperatively these patients also had higher left ventricular mid- and end-diastolic pressures at similar diastolic volumes, suggesting a decrease in chamber compliance. Thus, late after aortic valve replacement there is a subgroup of patients who, despite normal hemodynamics and normal left ventricular systolic function as assessed by the left ventricular ejection fraction at rest, have an abnormal response to exercise characterized primarily by a substantial rise in left heart filling pressures. Preoperatively this group also has a decrease in diastolic chamber compliance despite nearly normal left ventricular ejection fractions. This abnormality appears to result from a primary derangement of diastolic function that is not evident at rest.
我们研究了20例主动脉瓣置换术后晚期(10±2年)患者(12例为主动脉瓣狭窄,6例为主动脉瓣关闭不全,2例为狭窄合并关闭不全)对仰卧位自行车运动的血流动力学反应。采用肺动脉球囊导管测定肺动脉楔压,并在向肺动脉内注入造影剂后通过数字减影血管造影术进行左心室造影。将这些患者与11名无心脏病或仅有轻微心脏病的对照受试者进行比较,这些对照受试者因胸痛进行常规检查,测定了左心室舒张末期压力并进行了直接造影心室造影。与对照人群相比,研究人群的左心充盈压相似(7±3 vs 9±3 mmHg,无显著性差异),但左心室射血分数更高(75±7% vs 67±7%,p<0.02),左心室肌肉质量指数更高(106±28 vs 85±9 g/m²,p<0.01)。与对照受试者相比,研究人群中升高的心肌质量导致收缩期壁应力更低(254±65 vs 320±49×10³达因/cm²,p<0.01),这可能解释了观察到的更高射血分数。14例患者运动反应正常(对照受试者左心充盈压为16±4 vs 18±2 mmHg,无显著性差异;对照受试者左心室射血分数为77±8% vs 73±5%,无显著性差异)。然而,其余6例患者虽然运动时左心室射血分数正常(72±9%,无显著性差异),但左心充盈压异常升高(33±8 mmHg,p<0.01)。术前这些患者在相似舒张容积时左心室舒张中期和末期压力也更高,提示心室顺应性降低。因此,主动脉瓣置换术后晚期有一部分患者,尽管静息时通过左心室射血分数评估血流动力学正常且左心室收缩功能正常,但运动反应异常,主要表现为左心充盈压大幅升高。术前这组患者尽管左心室射血分数接近正常,但舒张期心室顺应性也降低。这种异常似乎源于舒张功能的原发性紊乱,静息时并不明显。