The generation of anti-PEG antibodies in response to PEGylated proteins, peptides, and carriers significantly limits their clinical applicability. IgM antibodies mediate the clearance of these therapeutics upon repeat injection, resulting in toxicity and hindered therapeutic efficacy. We observed this phenomenon in our polymer platform, virus-inspired polymer for endosomal release (VIPER), which employs pH-sensitive triggered display of a lytic peptide, melittin, to facilitate endosomal escape. While the polymer-peptide conjugate was well tolerated after a single injection, we observed unexpected mortality upon repeat injection. Thus, the goal of this work was to enhance the safety and tolerability of VIPER for frequent dosing. Based on previous reports on anti-PEG antibodies and the adjuvant activity of melittin, we characterized the antibody response to polymer, peptide, and polymer-peptide conjugates after repeat-dosing and measured high IgM titers that bound PEG. By substituting the L-amino acid peptide for its D-amino acid enantiomer, we significantly attenuated the anti-PEG antibody generation and toxicity, permitting repeat-injections. We attempted to rescue mice from L-melittin induced toxicity by prophylactic injection of platelet activating factor (PAF) antagonist CV-6209, but observed minimal effect, suggesting that PAF is not the primary mediator of the observed hypersensitivity response. Overall, we demonstrated that the D-amino acid polymer-peptide conjugates, unlike L-amino acid polymer-peptide conjugates, exhibit good tolerability in vivo, even upon repeat administration, and do not elicit the generation of anti-PEG antibodies.