Reed Tamsen, Mason Lisa Reyes, Ekenga Christine C
Brown School, Washington University in St. Louis, St. Louis, MO, USA.
Department of City and Regional Planning, University of North Carolina Chapel Hill, Chapel Hill, NC, USA.
Environ Health Insights. 2020 Dec 28;14:1178630220984153. doi: 10.1177/1178630220984153. eCollection 2020.
In the Midwestern United States (US), river flooding is a climate change-related hazard that poses a significant threat to health, well-being and economic stability. The 2019 Midwest floods led to major flooding at every monitoring site along the Mississippi River, set record water levels at 42 sites, and resulted in an estimated $6.2 billion in infrastructure damage and recovery costs. Although the risks associated with increasing flooding in the Midwestern US have been well recognized, less is known about the adaptation challenges and opportunities in the region, particularly in the Upper Mississippi River Basin. This exploratory study examined stakeholder perspectives on river system management, flood risk reduction, and adaptation planning in the Upper Mississippi River Basin. We conducted in-depth interviews with flood management stakeholders between August and October 2019. Interview data were analyzed using thematic analysis. Five themes emerged from the interviews: (1) River flooding in the Midwestern US is a different experience than US coastal flooding; (2) River flooding in the Midwestern US is a regional experience that requires a regional response; (3) Local actors face constrained resources for flood risk protection and recovery; (4) Differentiated responsibility across levels of governments makes recovery and response difficult to navigate; and (5) Competing stakeholder goals challenge cooperative flood hazard management. Overall, these results suggest that locally focused adaptation efforts, while perhaps appropriate for coastal communities or more urban contexts, are suboptimal strategies for communities in the flood-prone river basins of the Midwestern US. Instead, structures and support for regional collaboration should be considered and pursued.
在美国中西部,河流洪水是一种与气候变化相关的灾害,对健康、福祉和经济稳定构成重大威胁。2019年的中西部洪水导致密西西比河沿岸每个监测点都发生了重大洪水,42个地点创下了水位纪录,造成基础设施损坏和恢复成本估计达62亿美元。尽管美国中西部洪水增加带来的风险已得到充分认识,但对于该地区,尤其是密西西比河上游流域的适应挑战和机遇却知之甚少。这项探索性研究考察了利益相关者对密西西比河上游流域河流系统管理、洪水风险降低和适应规划的看法。我们在2019年8月至10月期间对洪水管理利益相关者进行了深入访谈。使用主题分析法对访谈数据进行了分析。访谈中出现了五个主题:(1)美国中西部的河流洪水与美国沿海洪水的情况不同;(2)美国中西部的河流洪水是一种区域性现象,需要区域层面的应对措施;(3)当地行动者在洪水风险防范和恢复方面面临资源受限的问题;(4)各级政府责任划分不同,使得恢复和应对工作难以开展;(5)相互竞争的利益相关者目标对合作性洪水灾害管理构成挑战。总体而言,这些结果表明,以地方为重点的适应努力,虽然可能适用于沿海社区或城市化程度更高的地区,但对于美国中西部洪水多发河流流域的社区来说并非最优策略。相反,应考虑并推动建立区域合作的架构和支持机制。