Simon Shauna G, Sloan Richard P, Thayer Julian F, Jamner Larry D
Department of Psychological Science, University of California Irvine, Irvine, CA, USA.
Division of Behavioral Medicine, Department of Psychiatry, New York State Psychiatric Institute, Columbia University, New York, NY, USA.
Psychophysiology. 2021 Apr;58(4):e13765. doi: 10.1111/psyp.13765. Epub 2021 Jan 16.
Emotions have long been discussed in conjunction with the autonomic nervous system. Most research on emotion-autonomic linkages does not consider sex differences or an evident underlying mechanism for sex differences: menstrual cycle phase. Further, most research is limited to cross-sectional and laboratory studies. The degree to which emotion-autonomic associations manifest in everyday life may be different and may vary by sex and, for women, by menstrual cycle phase. This study employs the ambulatory monitoring of cardiovascular measures (e.g., heart rate and heart rate variability; HRV) and concurrent emotional states (e.g., sadness, stress, anxiety, anger, and happiness) in everyday life to better characterize emotion-autonomic associations as a function of sex and menstrual cycle phase. Participants (N = 174; 87 female) ages 18 to 46 (31.23 ± 6.49) were monitored over a 5-day observation period (one 2- and one 3-day session), using an ambulatory 24-hour electrocardiogram to monitor heart rate and ecological momentary assessment to record emotions every ~30 min. Women were monitored in both the early to mid-follicular and -luteal phases and men in two comparably distanced sessions. Multilevel models indicated that across sex, negative emotions and happiness were associated with elevated heart rate. Relative to men, women exhibited an elevated heart rate and reduced HRV during reports of anger. For women, during the luteal phase, but not follicular phase, momentary sadness, stress, and anxiety predicted increased heart rate and reduced HRV. These findings demonstrate the importance of considering sex and menstrual cycle phase in research investigating emotion-autonomic linkages.
长期以来,情绪一直与自主神经系统联系在一起进行讨论。大多数关于情绪与自主神经联系的研究没有考虑性别差异或性别差异的明显潜在机制:月经周期阶段。此外,大多数研究仅限于横断面研究和实验室研究。情绪与自主神经的关联在日常生活中表现的程度可能不同,并且可能因性别而异,对于女性而言,还可能因月经周期阶段而异。本研究采用动态监测日常生活中的心血管指标(如心率和心率变异性;HRV)以及同时出现的情绪状态(如悲伤、压力、焦虑、愤怒和快乐),以更好地描述情绪与自主神经关联如何随性别和月经周期阶段而变化。研究对象为174名年龄在18至46岁(31.23±6.49)之间的参与者(87名女性),在为期5天的观察期内(一次2天和一次3天的时段)进行监测,使用动态24小时心电图监测心率,并采用生态瞬时评估法每30分钟左右记录一次情绪。女性在卵泡期早期至中期和黄体期均接受监测,男性则在两个距离相当的时段接受监测。多层次模型表明,在不同性别中,负面情绪和快乐都与心率升高有关。相对于男性,女性在报告愤怒情绪时心率升高且HRV降低。对于女性来说,在黄体期而非卵泡期,瞬时悲伤、压力和焦虑预示着心率增加和HRV降低。这些发现证明了在研究情绪与自主神经联系时考虑性别和月经周期阶段的重要性。