Department of Rehabilitation Medicine, The Fifth Affiliated Hospital of Guangzhou Medical University, Guangzhou, Guangdong, China (mainland).
Department of Rehabilitation Medicine, Guangzhou Medical University, Guangzhou, Guangdong, China (mainland).
Med Sci Monit. 2021 Jan 17;27:e929834. doi: 10.12659/MSM.929834.
BACKGROUND Learning medical English is particularly challenging for non-native English-speaking medical students. The Smart Class teaching module is a new online teaching module for rehabilitation-related medical English, the efficacy of which has yet to be established in the literature. Gender differences should also not be ignored in our study, taking into account the proven performance differences between males and females in language learning. MATERIAL AND METHODS First-year physiotherapy students in Grade 2018 and Grade 2019 at Guangzhou Medical University were recruited to participate in this study. Grade 2019, as the experimental group, completed the Smart Class teaching module, while Grade 2018, as the control group, completed the Traditional Class teaching module. The efficacy of both modules was assessed objectively using the students' medical English exam scores and subjectively using the students' responses to a questionnaire. RESULTS In total, 242 questionnaires were distributed, and 210 valid questionnaires were returned, of which 119 were from the Smart Class teaching module group and 91 were from the Traditional Class teaching module group. There was no statistically significant difference between the medical English exam scores of the 2 groups (P=0.324). However, the subjective assessment revealed that the students experienced a significantly greater burden from the workload in the Smart Class teaching module group (P<0.001). CONCLUSIONS We found both the Smart Class teaching module and the Traditional Class teaching module achieved similar teaching outcomes. Therefore, the former represents a viable alternative teaching option for situations where traditional class teaching is not possible.
对于非英语母语的医学专业学生来说,学习医学英语尤其具有挑战性。智能课堂教学模块是一种新的康复相关医学英语在线教学模块,其在文献中尚未得到证实。在我们的研究中,还不应忽视性别差异,因为在语言学习方面,已经证明男性和女性之间存在表现差异。
广州医科大学 2018 级和 2019 级物理治疗专业的一年级学生被招募参与本研究。2019 级作为实验组完成智能课堂教学模块,而 2018 级作为对照组完成传统课堂教学模块。通过学生的医学英语考试成绩和对问卷的回答,客观评估两个模块的效果。
共发放 242 份问卷,回收 210 份有效问卷,其中智能课堂教学模块组 119 份,传统课堂教学模块组 91 份。两组的医学英语考试成绩无统计学差异(P=0.324)。然而,主观评估显示,智能课堂教学模块组的学生在工作量方面感到明显更大的负担(P<0.001)。
我们发现智能课堂教学模块和传统课堂教学模块都取得了相似的教学效果。因此,在传统课堂教学无法实现的情况下,前者是一种可行的替代教学选择。