Kassianos George, Banerjee Ashis, Baron-Papillon Florence, Hampson Alan W, McElhaney Janet E, McGeer Allison, Rigoine de Fougerolles Thierry, Rothholz Mitch, Seale Holly, Tan Litjen J, Thomson Angus, Vitoux Olivier
Royal College of General Practitioners, London, UK.
Public Health England, London, UK.
Drugs Context. 2021 Jan 5;10. doi: 10.7573/dic.2020-9-5. eCollection 2021.
Many countries consistently fail to achieve the target influenza vaccine coverage rate (VCR) of 75% for populations at risk of complications, recommended by the World Health Organization and European Council. We aimed to identify factors for achieving a high VCR in the scope of four benchmark countries with high influenza VCRs: Australia, Canada, UK and USA.
Publicly available evidence was first reviewed at a global level and then for each of the four countries. Semi-structured interviews were then conducted with stakeholders meeting predefined criteria. Descriptive cluster analyses were performed to identify key factors and pillars for establishing and maintaining high VCRs.
No single factor led to a high VCR, and each benchmark country used a different combination of tailored approaches to achieve a high vaccine coverage. In each country, specific triggers were important to stimulate changes that led to improved vaccine coverage. A total of 42 key factors for a successful influenza vaccination programme were identified and clustered into five pillars: (1) Health Authority accountability and strengths of the influenza programme, (2) facilitated access to vaccination, (3) healthcare professional accountability and engagement, (4) awareness of the burden and severity of disease and (5) belief in influenza vaccination benefit. Each benchmark country has implemented multiple factors from each pillar.
A wide range of factors were identified from an evaluation of four high-performing benchmark countries, classified into five pillars, thus providing a basis for countries with lower VCRs to tailor their own particular solutions to improve their influenza VCR.
许多国家一直未能达到世界卫生组织和欧洲理事会建议的针对有并发症风险人群的75%的目标流感疫苗接种覆盖率(VCR)。我们旨在确定在四个流感疫苗接种覆盖率高的基准国家(澳大利亚、加拿大、英国和美国)范围内实现高VCR的因素。
首先在全球范围内审查公开可得的证据,然后针对四个国家中的每一个进行审查。随后对符合预定义标准的利益相关者进行半结构化访谈。进行描述性聚类分析以确定建立和维持高VCR的关键因素和支柱。
没有单一因素导致高VCR,每个基准国家都采用了不同的定制方法组合来实现高疫苗接种覆盖率。在每个国家,特定的触发因素对于刺激导致疫苗接种覆盖率提高的变化很重要。共确定了成功的流感疫苗接种计划的42个关键因素,并将其聚类为五个支柱:(1)卫生当局的问责制和流感计划的优势,(2)便利的疫苗接种途径,(3)医疗保健专业人员的问责制和参与度,(4)对疾病负担和严重性的认识,以及(5)对流感疫苗接种益处的信念。每个基准国家都实施了来自每个支柱的多个因素。
通过对四个表现出色的基准国家的评估确定了广泛的因素,这些因素分为五个支柱,从而为VCR较低的国家提供了依据,使其能够量身定制自己的特定解决方案以提高其流感VCR。