Xu Xu, Zhang Jin-Ge, Peng Wan-Lin, Liu Ke-Ling, Hu Si-Xian, Zeng Ling-Ming, Xia Chun-Chao, Li Zhen-Lin
Department of Radiology, West China Hospital, Sichuan University, Chengdu 610041, China.
Sichuan Da Xue Xue Bao Yi Xue Ban. 2021 Jan;52(1):92-97. doi: 10.12182/20210160602.
To evaluate the diagnostic value of 3.0T time-of-flight MR angiography with sparse undersampling and iterative reconstruction (TOFu-MRA) for unruptured intracranial aneurysms (UIAs) on the basis of using digital subtraction angiography (DSA) as the reference standard.
A total of 65 patients with suspected UIAs were prospectively enrolled and all patients underwent TOFu-MRA and DSA. Relying on DSA as the reference standard, the sensitivity (SEN), specificity (SPE), positive predictive value (PPV) and negative predictive value (NPV) of using TOFu-MRA in UIA diagnosis were calculated, and the inter-observer agreement between two doctors was determined. Comparison of maximum intensity projection (MIP) and volume rendering (VR) image datasets was made to evaluate the agreement between DSA results and TOFu-MRA in the measurement of UIA morphological parameters, including the neck width (D ), height (H) , and width (D ) of UIAs.
The study covered 55 UIAs from 46 patients. The SEN, SPE, PPV and NPV of the two doctors using TOFu-MRA in UIA diagnosis were as follows: (95.7%, 95.7%), (94.7%, 94.7%), (97.8%, 97.8%) and (90.0%, 90.0%), respectively for patient-based assessment; (96.4%, 94.5%), (94.7%, 94.7%), (98.1%, 98.1%) and (90.0%, 85.7%), respectively, for aneurysm-based assessment. There is a strong inter-observer agreement (Kappa=0.93 for patient-based assessment and 0.96 for aneurysm-based assessment) between the two doctors. Moreover, Bland-Altman analysis showed that more than 95% points fell within the limits of agreement (LoA), suggesting strong agreement between the two examination methods for the measurement of UIAs morphological parameters.
TOFu-MRA showed good diagnostic efficacy for UIAs and the results were in good agreement with those of DSA, the reference standard, for assessing UIA morphological parameter. TOFu-MRA can be used as a first choice for noninvasive diagnostic evaluation of UIAs.
以数字减影血管造影(DSA)作为参考标准,评估3.0T时间飞跃法磁共振血管造影(TOFu-MRA)联合稀疏欠采样及迭代重建技术对未破裂颅内动脉瘤(UIA)的诊断价值。
前瞻性纳入65例疑似UIA患者,所有患者均接受TOFu-MRA和DSA检查。以DSA作为参考标准,计算TOFu-MRA诊断UIA的敏感度(SEN)、特异度(SPE)、阳性预测值(PPV)和阴性预测值(NPV),并确定两名医生之间的观察者间一致性。比较最大密度投影(MIP)和容积再现(VR)图像数据集,以评估DSA结果与TOFu-MRA在测量UIA形态学参数(包括UIA的颈部宽度(D)、高度(H)和宽度(D))方面的一致性。
该研究涵盖了46例患者的55个UIA。两名医生使用TOFu-MRA诊断UIA的SEN、SPE、PPV和NPV如下:基于患者评估分别为(95.7%,95.7%)、(94.7%,94.7%)、(97.8%,97.8%)和(90.0%,90.0%);基于动脉瘤评估分别为(96.4%,94.5%)、(94.7%,94.7%)、(98.1%,98.1%)和(90.0%,85.7%)。两名医生之间存在很强的观察者间一致性(基于患者评估的Kappa值为0.93,基于动脉瘤评估的Kappa值为0.96)。此外,Bland-Altman分析表明,超过95%的点落在一致性界限(LoA)内,表明两种检查方法在测量UIA形态学参数方面具有很强的一致性。
TOFu-MRA对UIA显示出良好的诊断效能,其结果与作为参考标准的DSA在评估UIA形态学参数方面具有良好的一致性。TOFu-MRA可作为UIA无创诊断评估的首选方法。