Tarp Jakob, Gejl Anne Kær, Hillman Charles H, Wedderkopp Niels, Bugge Anna
Department of Sports Medicine, Norwegian School of Sports Sciences, 0863 Oslo, Norway.
Department of Midwifery, Physiotherapy, Occupational Therapy and Psychomotor Therapy, Faculty of Health, University College Copenhagen, 1799 Copenhagen, Denmark.
Children (Basel). 2021 Jan 18;8(1):57. doi: 10.3390/children8010057.
It remains unclear whether the provision of additional physical activity in school improves academic outcomes. We conducted a secondary analysis of the Childhood Health, Activity, and Motor Performance School Study Denmark (CHAMPS-study DK), a natural experiment based on a trebling of curricular physical education, to investigate whether children receiving additional physical education performed better on their academic exams at the conclusion of compulsory education (i.e., 9th grade). Children from six intervention schools received 3-7 years of exposure to 270 weekly minutes of physical education (sports schools), while children from four control schools received the 90-min national standard (normal schools). Academic performance was based on the standard Danish 7-point scale (ranging from -03 to 12) and retrieved from national registries. The primary outcome was calculated as the average exam grade. Comparisons of participants at sports and normal schools were adjusted for individual socioeconomic factors and school-level academic environment. There were no differences in the pooled exam performance among 691 sports- and 510 normal-school participants (0.20 (95% confidence interval: -0.12 to 0.52)). Results for subject-specific exams indicated similar results. This analysis from a non-randomized natural experiment did not provide evidence that simply adding additional physical education is sufficient to affect academic performance relative to the national standard.
目前尚不清楚在学校增加体育活动是否能提高学业成绩。我们对丹麦儿童健康、活动和运动表现学校研究(CHAMPS - study DK)进行了二次分析,这是一项基于将体育课课时增加两倍的自然实验,旨在调查接受额外体育课的儿童在义务教育结束时(即九年级)的学业考试中是否表现更好。来自六所干预学校的儿童接受了3至7年每周270分钟的体育教育(体育学校),而来自四所对照学校的儿童接受90分钟的国家标准体育教育(普通学校)。学业成绩基于丹麦标准的7分制(范围从 -0.3到1.2),并从国家登记处获取。主要结果以平均考试成绩计算。对体育学校和普通学校参与者的比较针对个体社会经济因素和学校层面的学术环境进行了调整。691名体育学校参与者和510名普通学校参与者的综合考试成绩没有差异(0.20(95%置信区间:-0.12至0.52))。特定学科考试的结果也显示了类似的结果。这项来自非随机自然实验的分析没有提供证据表明,相对于国家标准,仅仅增加体育课不足以影响学业成绩。