Eckert Ester M, Anicic Nikoleta, Fontaneto Diego
MEG- Molecular Ecology Group, Water Research Institute, National Research Council of Italy (CNR-IRSA), Verbania, Italy.
Laboratory of Applied Microbiology, Department of Environment, Construction and Design, University of Applied Sciences and Arts of Southern Switzerland, Bellinzona, Switzerland.
Mol Ecol. 2021 Mar;30(6):1545-1558. doi: 10.1111/mec.15815. Epub 2021 Feb 25.
The association with microbes in plants and animals is known to be beneficial for host's survival and fitness, but the generality of the effect of the microbiome is still debated. For some animals, similarities in microbiome composition reflect taxonomic relatedness of the hosts, a pattern termed phylosymbiosis. The mechanisms behind the pattern could be due to co-evolution and/or to correlated ecological constraints. General conclusions are hampered by the fact that available knowledge is highly dominated by microbiomes from model species. Here, we addressed the issue of the generality of phylosymbiosis by analysing the species-specificity of microbiomes across different species of freshwater zooplankton, including rotifers, cladocerans, and copepods, coupling field surveys and experimental manipulations. We found that no signal of phylosymbiosis was present, and that the proportion of "core" microbial taxa, stable and consistent within each species, was very low. Changes in food and temperature under laboratory experimental settings revealed that the microbiome of freshwater zooplankton is highly flexible and can be influenced by the external environment. Thus, the role of co-evolution, strict association, and interaction with microbes within the holobiont concept highlighted for vertebrates, corals, sponges, and other animals does not seem to be supported for all animals, at least not for freshwater zooplankton. Zooplankton floats in the environment where both food and bacteria that can provide help in digesting such food are available. In addition, there is probably redundancy for beneficial bacterial functions in the environment, not allowing a strict host-microbiome association to originate and persist.
已知动植物与微生物的关联对宿主的生存和健康有益,但微生物组效应的普遍性仍存在争议。对于一些动物而言,微生物组组成的相似性反映了宿主的分类学亲缘关系,这种模式被称为系统共生。该模式背后的机制可能是共同进化和/或相关的生态限制。现有知识高度集中于模式物种的微生物组,这一事实阻碍了得出一般性结论。在此,我们通过分析不同种类淡水浮游动物(包括轮虫、枝角类和桡足类)微生物组的物种特异性,并结合野外调查和实验操作,探讨了系统共生的普遍性问题。我们发现不存在系统共生的信号,且每个物种内稳定且一致的“核心”微生物类群的比例非常低。实验室实验环境下食物和温度的变化表明,淡水浮游动物的微生物组具有高度灵活性,可受外部环境影响。因此,在脊椎动物、珊瑚、海绵和其他动物中所强调的全生物概念内共同进化、严格关联以及与微生物相互作用的作用,似乎并不适用于所有动物,至少不适用于淡水浮游动物。浮游动物漂浮在既有食物又有能帮助消化此类食物的细菌的环境中。此外,环境中有益细菌功能可能存在冗余,这使得严格的宿主 - 微生物组关联无法产生并持续存在。