Nestor Mark, Cohen Joel L, Landau Marina, Hilton Said, Nikolis Andreas, Haq Syed, Viel Maurizio, Andriopoulos Bill, Prygova Inna, Foster Keith, Redaelli Alessio, Picaut Philippe
Dr. Nestor is with the Miller School of Medicine at the University of Miami in Miami, Florida, and the Center for Cosmetic Enhancement and Center for Clinical and Cosmetic Research in Aventura, Florida.
Dr. Cohen is with AboutSkin Dermatology and DermSurgery in Greenwood Village and Lone Tree, Colorado and the University of California, Irvine, in Irvine, California.
J Clin Aesthet Dermatol. 2020 Dec;13(12):E56-E83. Epub 2020 Dec 1.
We sought to analyze the current literature regarding time to onset and duration of effect of abobotulinumtoxinA (aboBoNT-A, Dysport®/Azzalure®) for upper facial aesthetic indications. We conducted a systematic review of literature databases (PubMed/MEDLINE, Embase, Cochrane Library, and Google Scholar) to identify English-language publications relevant to: population (patients with aesthetic indications [including glabellar lines and wrinkles]); interventions (aboBoNT-A); comparators (no restrictions); outcomes (efficacy, including onset of action and duration of effect); and settings (clinical). A manual search of review paper bibliographies was performed. Structured data extraction was used to enable interstudy analysis. Overall, 42 original research papers relevant to aboBoNT-A onset and/or duration were identified. All 24 studies assessing efficacy within one week post-injection demonstrated some response at the first time point assessed, and all 37 studies assessing duration showed some response after 12 weeks. Although methodologies for assessing onset and duration differed, when outcomes were refined by reported mean/median, at least 50 percent of patients responding to treatment, or significance versus placebo or baseline at a given time point, onset was most often reported within 2 to 3 days (7 studies), and as early as 24 hours (2 studies). Duration was most often reported as four months (18 studies), although four studies provided evidence that aboBoNT-A efficacy was maintained at five months and three studies at or after six months post-injection. This review indicates that aboBoNT-A has a median onset of efficacy of 2 to 3 days and a longer duration of action (3-6 months across studies) than the current labelled minimum treatment interval (12 weeks).
我们试图分析当前关于阿柏西普肉毒毒素A(aboBoNT - A,Dysport®/Azzalure®)用于面部上半部分美学适应症的起效时间和作用持续时间的文献。我们对文献数据库(PubMed/MEDLINE、Embase、Cochrane图书馆和谷歌学术)进行了系统综述,以确定与以下内容相关的英文出版物:人群(有美学适应症的患者[包括眉间纹和皱纹]);干预措施(aboBoNT - A);对照(无限制);结果(疗效,包括起效时间和作用持续时间);以及环境(临床)。对手稿参考文献进行了人工检索。采用结构化数据提取以进行研究间分析。总体而言,共确定了42篇与aboBoNT - A起效和/或持续时间相关的原创研究论文。所有24项在注射后一周内评估疗效的研究在首次评估时间点均显示出一定反应,所有37项评估持续时间的研究在12周后均显示出一定反应。尽管评估起效和持续时间的方法有所不同,但当按报告的均值/中位数、至少50%的治疗反应患者或给定时间点与安慰剂或基线相比的显著性来细化结果时,起效时间最常报告为2至3天(7项研究),最早为24小时(2项研究)。持续时间最常报告为四个月(18项研究),不过有四项研究提供证据表明aboBoNT - A的疗效在注射后五个月仍得以维持,三项研究表明在六个月及六个月后仍得以维持。本综述表明,aboBoNT - A的疗效起效中位数为2至3天,作用持续时间(各研究为3 - 6个月)比当前标注的最短治疗间隔(12周)更长。