Smit Riekie, Gubanova Elena, Kaufman Joely, Landau Marina, Molina Beatriz, Andriopoulos Bill, Maisonobe Pascal, Prygova Inna, Redaelli Alessio
Dr. Smit is with the Dr. Riekie Smit Aesthetic Medical Practice in Pretoria, South Africa.
Dr. Gubanova is with Vallex Med Clinic of Preventive Medicine, Moscow National University of Food Production in Moscow, Russian Federation.
J Clin Aesthet Dermatol. 2021 Feb;14(2):E69-E88. Epub 2021 Feb 1.
AbobotulinumtoxinA (AboBoNT-A; Dysport; Ipsen, Boulogne-Billancourt, France/Azzalure; Galderma, Lausanne, Switzerland) is a botulinum neurotoxin type A approved for aesthetic use in the treatment of glabellar lines in adult patients under 65 years in Europe, the United States, and other countries. We sought to analyze current literature on patient satisfaction with aboBoNT-A for upper facial aesthetic indications. A systematic review of literature databases (PubMed/MEDLINE, Embase, the Cochrane Library, and Google Scholar) was performed to identify English-language publications reporting on patients with aesthetic indications (including glabellar lines and wrinkles) receiving aboBoNT-A, that assessed patient and/or physician satisfaction with treatment, with no restrictions on comparator studies. Structured data extraction was used to enable inter-study analysis. A analysis was also performed to assess patient satisfaction by sex and age, using results from the noninterventional APPEAL study of patients' satisfaction with aboBoNT-A for treating glabellar lines. Overall, 22 original research papers were identified. Patient satisfaction rates for aboBoNT-A treatment were significantly higher versus placebo from two weeks to between three and five months postinjection. At two to three weeks postinjection, patient satisfaction rates were 52% and 99% across studies. In studies with later time points, patient satisfaction rates were 85 to 87 percent at 5 months and between 25 and 100 percent at 6 months post-injection. Physician satisfaction was also high (97%-100%, across three treatments). No notable differences in patient satisfaction by sex or age were observed in the APPEAL study. High rates of patient satisfaction have been achieved with aboBoNT-A treatment for upper facial aesthetic indications. Despite the current recommended interval of ≥12 weeks, satisfaction with the aesthetic results of aboBoNT-A therapy is still evident up to 6 months post-injection in some patients.
阿柏毒素A(AboBoNT - A;Dysport;益普生公司,法国布洛涅 - 比扬古/阿佐卢尔;高德美公司,瑞士洛桑)是一种A型肉毒杆菌神经毒素,在欧洲、美国和其他国家被批准用于美容,治疗65岁以下成年患者的眉间纹。我们试图分析当前关于患者对AboBoNT - A用于面部上半部分美容适应症满意度的文献。对文献数据库(PubMed/MEDLINE、Embase、Cochrane图书馆和谷歌学术)进行了系统综述,以识别英文出版物,这些出版物报告了接受AboBoNT - A治疗的有美容适应症(包括眉间纹和皱纹)的患者,评估了患者和/或医生对治疗的满意度,对对照研究没有限制。采用结构化数据提取以进行研究间分析。还使用了关于患者对AboBoNT - A治疗眉间纹满意度的非干预性APPEAL研究结果,按性别和年龄进行分析以评估患者满意度。总体而言,共识别出22篇原创研究论文。注射后两周至三到五个月期间,AboBoNT - A治疗的患者满意度显著高于安慰剂。注射后两到三周,各研究的患者满意度分别为52%和99%。在有更后期时间点的研究中,注射后5个月时患者满意度为85%至87%,6个月时为25%至100%。医生满意度也很高(三种治疗方式总体为97% - 100%)。在APPEAL研究中,未观察到患者满意度在性别或年龄上有显著差异。AboBoNT - A治疗面部上半部分美容适应症已取得较高的患者满意度。尽管目前推荐的间隔时间≥12周,但在一些患者中,注射后长达6个月时,对AboBoNT - A治疗美学效果的满意度仍然明显。