Department of Medicine, University of Ottawa, Ottawa, Canada.
Division of Critical Care Medicine, Niagara Health, St. Catharines, Canada.
J Eval Clin Pract. 2021 Dec;27(6):1281-1290. doi: 10.1111/jep.13538. Epub 2021 Jan 26.
The end of life (EOL) experience in the intensive care unit (ICU) can be psychologically distressing for patients, families, and clinicians. The 3 Wishes Project (3WP) personalizes the EOL experience by carrying out wishes for dying patients and their families. While the 3WP has been integrated in academic, tertiary care ICUs, implementing this project in a community ICU has yet to be described.
To examine facilitators of, and barriers to, implementing the 3WP in a community ICU from the clinician and implementation team perspective.
This qualitative descriptive study evaluated the implementation of the 3WP in a 20-bed community ICU in Southern Ontario, Canada. Patients were considered for the 3WP if they had a high likelihood of imminent death or planned withdrawal of life-sustaining therapy. Following the qualitative descriptive approach, semi-structured interviews were conducted with purposively sampled clinicians and implementation team. Data from transcribed interviews were analyzed in triplicate through qualitative content analysis.
Interviews with 12 participants indicated that the 3WP personalized and enriched the EOL experience. Interviewees indicated higher intensity education strategies were needed to enable spread as the project grew. Clinicians described many physical resources for the project but suggested more non-clinical project support for orientation, continuing education, and data collection. A majority of wishes focused on physical resources including keepsakes, which helped facilitate project spread when clinician capacity was attenuated by competing duties.
In this community hospital, ICU clinicians and implementation team members report perceived improved EOL care for patients, families, and clinicians following 3WP initiation and integration. Implementing individualized and meaningful wishes at EOL for dying patients in a community ICU requires adequate planning and time dedicated to optimizing clinician education. Adapting key features of an intervention to local expertise and capacity may facilitate spread during project initiation and integration.
重症监护病房(ICU)的临终体验可能会给患者、家属和临床医生带来心理困扰。3 个愿望项目(3WP)通过实现临终患者及其家属的愿望来实现临终体验的个性化。虽然 3WP 已经整合到学术性、三级护理 ICU 中,但在社区 ICU 中实施这一项目尚未得到描述。
从临床医生和实施团队的角度,探讨在社区 ICU 中实施 3WP 的促进因素和障碍。
本定性描述性研究评估了加拿大安大略省南部一家 20 床社区 ICU 中 3WP 的实施情况。如果患者有即将死亡或计划停止维持生命治疗的高可能性,则考虑将其纳入 3WP。在定性描述方法的基础上,对有目的抽样的临床医生和实施团队进行了半结构化访谈。通过定性内容分析对转录访谈数据进行了三重分析。
对 12 名参与者的访谈表明,3WP 使临终体验个性化和丰富化。受访者表示,随着项目的发展,需要更强化的教育策略来实现项目的推广。临床医生描述了许多项目的物理资源,但建议为定向、继续教育和数据收集提供更多非临床项目支持。大多数愿望都集中在物理资源上,包括纪念品,这有助于在临床医生的工作量因其他职责而减少时,促进项目的推广。
在这家社区医院中,ICU 临床医生和实施团队成员报告称,在实施和整合 3WP 后,患者、家属和临床医生的临终护理得到了改善。在社区 ICU 中,为临终患者实施个体化和有意义的愿望需要充分的计划和时间,以优化临床医生的教育。根据当地专业知识和能力调整干预措施的关键特征,可能有助于在项目启动和整合过程中促进项目的推广。