Holder Nicholas, Kanady Jennifer C, Straus Laura D, Khan Amanda J, Purcell Natalie, Huggins Joy, Gloria Rebecca, Neylan Thomas C, Lujan Callan, Maguen Shira
San Francisco Veterans Affairs Health Care System, Mental Health, San Francisco, CA, USA.
Sierra Pacific Mental Illness Research, Education, and Clinical Center; Mental Health, San Francisco, CA, USA.
Behav Sleep Med. 2022 Jan-Feb;20(1):37-49. doi: 10.1080/15402002.2021.1878173. Epub 2021 Jan 27.
Although behavioral treatments are recommended for treating insomnia disorder, these treatments are not the most commonly provided treatments due to numerous barriers (e.g., treatment length, time limitations). Brief Behavioral Treatment for Insomnia (BBTI) was developed, in part, to help overcome these barriers. The purpose of the current study was to qualitatively examine the treatment experiences of veterans with insomnia disorder participating in BBTI. All veterans (n=46) who were randomized to receive BBTI as part of a randomized clinical trial participated in 10-20 minute semi-structured interviews one week after completing treatment. Rapid analysis procedures were used for qualitative analysis. Thirteen qualitative themes were identified: BBTI provided veterans with the skills they believed they needed to continue improving independently post-treatment; beginning BBTI with in-person sessions was valued; phone sessions helped participation; veterans did not perceive that they could cover the same content during phone and in-person sessionsl; materials could be more portable; BBTI created accountability; BBTI required discipline and willingness; BBTI facilitated buy-in; BBTI was aligned with military culture; loved ones could provide important support; BBTI could be improved with more personalization; BBTI challenged expectations of mental health; and BBTI improved awareness of health behaviors beyond sleep. BBTI was successful in overcoming barriers to behavioral insomnia treatment and interviews identified critical treatment aspects that should be maintained to preserve acceptability (e.g., in-person session first). Areas in which BBTI did not fully meet the needs of veterans and targets for improvement (e.g., ameliorating understanding and expectations of phone sessions) were also identified.
尽管行为疗法被推荐用于治疗失眠症,但由于诸多障碍(如治疗时长、时间限制),这些疗法并非最常用的治疗方法。简短行为性失眠治疗法(BBTI)的开发部分是为了帮助克服这些障碍。本研究的目的是定性考察参与BBTI的失眠症退伍军人的治疗体验。所有被随机分配接受BBTI作为随机临床试验一部分的退伍军人(n = 46)在完成治疗一周后参加了10 - 20分钟的半结构化访谈。采用快速分析程序进行定性分析。确定了13个定性主题:BBTI为退伍军人提供了他们认为在治疗后继续独立改善所需的技能;重视以面对面治疗开始BBTI;电话治疗有助于参与;退伍军人认为他们在电话治疗和面对面治疗中无法涵盖相同的内容;材料可以更便于携带;BBTI建立了责任感;BBTI需要自律和意愿;BBTI促进了认同;BBTI与军事文化相符;亲人可以提供重要支持;BBTI可以通过更多个性化得到改进;BBTI挑战了对心理健康的期望;BBTI提高了对睡眠以外健康行为的认识。BBTI成功克服了行为性失眠治疗的障碍,访谈确定了应保持以维持可接受性的关键治疗方面(如首先进行面对面治疗)。还确定了BBTI未完全满足退伍军人需求的领域以及改进目标(如改善对电话治疗的理解和期望)。