Department of Medical Sciences, iBiMED-Institute of Biomedicine, University of Aveiro, Aveiro, Portugal.
Department of Communication and Art/DigiMedia, University of Aveiro, Aveiro, Portugal.
J Med Internet Res. 2021 Jan 28;23(1):e19194. doi: 10.2196/19194.
The misuse of antibiotics is a global public health issue that fosters bacterial resistance and jeopardizes generational health. The development of validated tools such as web-based courses and mobile apps to enhance clinical decisions in upper respiratory infections is of great importance in reducing the incorrect use of antibiotics in these situations.
The aim of this study was to design and prevalidate the interface of a mobile app to assist and provide clinical support in the diagnosis of upper respiratory problems. We aimed to assess the adequacy and usability of the interface of the tool in the belief that it could be beneficial to health care delivery in the clinical decision setting.
Using a co-design approach that brought together professionals in interface design and experts in pharmacology and pharmacoepidemiology, the mobile app interface was evaluated through peer review sessions held by interface design professionals on a heuristic survey. The reviewers accessed a high-fidelity interactive mock-up of the interface and filled in a questionnaire to assess the dimensions of layout and visual design and navigation and tasks. The resulting feedback of this evaluation supported the redesign of the primary interface, which was assessed for the second time by 2 of the previously mentioned reviewers.
With 4 as the highest score, the interface scored a mean of 3.16 (SD 0.45; median of the means 3.2) for layout and visual design and a mean of 3.43 (SD 0.33; median of the means 3.51) for navigation and tasks, reflecting an overall positive evaluation. The open-ended commentaries allowed us to better understand specific recommendations of the reviewers. Throughout this section, approximately 0.98 comments per parameter were registered, reflecting a high level of effectiveness of the chosen parameters in identifying potential problems. The resultant beta version of the interface, addressing the majority of the detected problems, was further assessed by 2 of the previous reviewers, validating the new design. Future tests with physicians and pharmacists will help assess credibility and user experience dimensions.
Our study revealed that the designed interface is easy to interpret and use. Peer reviewers raised important issues that could be easily fixed and positively reassessed. As a result, the study enabled us to produce a new tool for interface usability assessment and a set of recommendations for developing mobile interfaces for clinical decision support systems in the scope of upper respiratory problems.
抗生素的滥用是一个全球性的公共卫生问题,它会助长细菌耐药性的产生,危及子孙后代的健康。开发经过验证的工具,如基于网络的课程和移动应用程序,以增强对上呼吸道感染的临床决策,对于减少这些情况下抗生素的不当使用非常重要。
本研究旨在设计和预验证一个移动应用程序的界面,以协助和提供上呼吸道问题诊断的临床支持。我们旨在评估该工具界面的充分性和可用性,因为我们相信它可能有助于在临床决策环境中提供医疗服务。
使用一种联合设计方法,将界面设计专业人员和药理学和药物流行病学专家聚集在一起,通过界面设计专业人员进行的同行评审会议评估移动应用程序界面。评审人员访问高保真度的界面交互模型,并填写一份问卷,以评估布局和视觉设计以及导航和任务的维度。评估产生的反馈支持了主要界面的重新设计,该界面由之前提到的 2 位评审人员进行了第二次评估。
界面在布局和视觉设计方面的平均得分为 3.16(SD 0.45;平均值的中位数为 3.2),在导航和任务方面的平均得分为 3.43(SD 0.33;平均值的中位数为 3.51),反映出总体上的积极评价。开放性评论使我们能够更好地理解评审人员的具体建议。在这一部分中,每个参数大约有 0.98 条评论,反映出所选参数在识别潜在问题方面的高度有效性。解决了大多数已发现问题的界面测试版进一步由之前的 2 位评审人员进行评估,验证了新设计。未来与医生和药剂师的测试将有助于评估可信度和用户体验维度。
我们的研究表明,设计的界面易于理解和使用。同行评审人员提出了一些重要的问题,这些问题很容易解决,并得到了积极的重新评估。因此,该研究使我们能够为界面可用性评估开发一个新工具,并为开发上呼吸道问题临床决策支持系统的移动界面提供一套建议。