Daniels G F, Garnett J E, Carter M F
Department of Urology, Northwestern University Medical School, Chicago, Illinois.
J Urol. 1988 Apr;139(4):710-3. doi: 10.1016/s0022-5347(17)42607-3.
Since its introduction for general use, the role of rigid ureteroscopy in the diagnosis and therapy of urological disease has been in evolution. We evaluated retrospectively the experience at our institution with rigid ureteroscopy from January 1983 to July 1986 in an attempt to identify clinical situations or techniques that tended to increase the incidence of either success or complications. We determined that ureteroscopic complications were rare in procedures performed for diagnosis compared to those performed for calculi (2 of 33 or 6 per cent versus 27 of 99 or 27 per cent, p less than 0.025). The likelihood of failure or complication was greater for stones above than for those below the pelvic brim (15 of 25 or 60 per cent versus 26 of 75 or 35 per cent, p less than 0.05). Major complications were more common early in our experience (9 of 63 or 14 per cent versus 2 of 69 or 3 per cent for the combined years 1983 and 1984 compared to 1985 and 1986, p less than 0.05). Our success rates in the treatment of calculous disease were similar to those reported previously, and they were somewhat better for stones located below (62 of 75 or 83 per cent) than for those above (17 of 25 or 68 per cent) the pelvic brim. Based on our findings we conclude that carefully performed diagnostic ureteroscopy has little potential for major complications, ureteroscopy for stones above the pelvic brim should be avoided when possible, and an increased rate of complications and failures is expected early in any series owing at least partly to the learning curve effect.
自从硬性输尿管镜被引入普遍使用以来,其在泌尿外科疾病诊断和治疗中的作用一直在演变。我们回顾性评估了1983年1月至1986年7月在我们机构使用硬性输尿管镜的经验,试图确定倾向于增加成功或并发症发生率的临床情况或技术。我们确定,与用于结石治疗的操作相比,诊断性操作中输尿管镜并发症很少见(33例中有2例,占6%,而99例中有27例,占27%,p<0.025)。盆腔边缘以上结石的失败或并发症可能性大于盆腔边缘以下结石(25例中有15例,占60%,而75例中有26例,占35%,p<0.05)。在我们的经验中,早期主要并发症更常见(1983年和1984年合计63例中有9例,占14%,而1985年和1986年69例中有2例,占3%,p<0.05)。我们在结石疾病治疗中的成功率与先前报道的相似,盆腔边缘以下结石的成功率(75例中有62例,占83%)略高于盆腔边缘以上结石(25例中有17例,占68%)。根据我们的发现,我们得出结论,仔细进行的诊断性输尿管镜检查发生重大并发症的可能性很小,应尽可能避免对盆腔边缘以上结石进行输尿管镜检查,并且在任何系列研究的早期,并发症和失败率增加至少部分归因于学习曲线效应。