Digestive Surgery Department, Regional Hospital Centre of Huy, Huy, Belgium.
Acta Chir Belg. 2022 Oct;122(5):321-327. doi: 10.1080/00015458.2020.1860551. Epub 2022 Jul 20.
Although medical treatment is the best approach for treating gastroesophageal reflux disease (GERD), surgery has a significant role to play not only in cases of failure of medical treatment but also as in a long-term approach, specifically in young patient. On the other hand, alarming reports have been published concerning the outcomes and usefulness of antireflux surgery (ARS). The aim of this study was to evaluate medium and long-term functional outcomes following ARS performed in our institution over a 10 year period. This was a retrospective review of patients in our department who underwent primary or redo laparoscopic fundoplication between 2005 and 2015. Evaluation of the outcomes was made using a validated questionnaire specifically dedicated to GERD (the Gastroesophageal Reflux Disease - Health-Related Quality of Life (GERD-HRQL) questionnaire) and by investigation about the continued use of proton-pump inhibitors (PPIs). Exclusion criteria were patients treated for GERD with Roux-en-Y gastric bypass, emergency reduction of hiatal hernia, patients missing from follow-up and patients deceased from unrelated causes. 296 patients out of 309 met the inclusion criteria. Primary procedures included 214 Nissen, 35 Toupet, and 23 Collis gastroplasty; there were additionally 62 redo operations. Neither postoperative mortality nor conversion was observed. The mean follow-up was 8 years post-surgery, and contact was made with 96% of the original group. 85% of the patients had stopped PPI use since their operation (86% after Nissen, 73% after Toupet, 94% after Collis and 82% after redos). 90% of the patients had good to excellent functional results as reported by their GERD-HRQL score, and independent of the type of previous procedure. 31 patients were dissatisfied due to dysphagia in 7 and GERD recurrence in 24. Again 75% were extremely satisfied and 15% satisfied. Our own incidence of redo procedures was 11% but the functional result and satisfaction index were comparable between redo and primary procedures. The addition of Collis gastroplasty in cases of real short oesophagus did not alter the final result. Laparoscopic ARS presents a superior alternative to lifetime medication use and can provide long-term control of GERD symptoms in the majority of patients if it is performed skillfully and in carefully evaluated patients. Based on the present study, we believed that significant improvement in GERD health-related quality of life can be attained following both primary and reoperative ARS.
尽管医学治疗是治疗胃食管反流病(GERD)的最佳方法,但手术不仅在治疗失败的情况下而且在长期治疗中都具有重要作用,特别是在年轻患者中。另一方面,有关抗反流手术(ARS)的结果和实用性的惊人报道已经发表。本研究的目的是评估我们机构在 10 年内进行的 ARS 的中远期功能结果。这是对我们部门在 2005 年至 2015 年间接受初次或再次腹腔镜胃底折叠术的患者进行的回顾性研究。使用专门针对 GERD 的经过验证的问卷(胃食管反流病 - 健康相关生活质量(GERD-HRQL)问卷)和关于质子泵抑制剂(PPIs)持续使用的调查来评估结果。排除标准为接受 Roux-en-Y 胃旁路手术治疗 GERD 的患者、紧急疝修复术、随访中缺失的患者和因非相关原因死亡的患者。309 名患者中有 296 名符合纳入标准。初次手术包括 214 例 Nissen 手术、35 例 Toupet 手术和 23 例 Collis 胃成形术;另外还有 62 例再次手术。术后无死亡或转换。术后平均随访 8 年,与原始组的 96%取得联系。85%的患者自手术后停止使用 PPI(Nissen 术后 86%,Toupet 术后 73%,Collis 术后 94%,再次手术后 82%)。90%的患者根据 GERD-HRQL 评分报告有良好至极好的功能结果,与先前手术类型无关。31 名患者因吞咽困难(7 名)和 GERD 复发(24 名)而不满意。同样,75%的患者非常满意,15%的患者满意。我们自己的再次手术发生率为 11%,但再次手术和初次手术之间的功能结果和满意度指数相似。如果熟练地进行手术并对经过仔细评估的患者进行手术,在真正短食管的情况下添加 Collis 胃成形术并不会改变最终结果。腹腔镜 ARS 为终生药物治疗提供了更好的替代方法,如果在熟练的医生手中进行,并且对经过仔细评估的患者进行,它可以为大多数患者提供长期的 GERD 症状控制。基于本研究,我们认为初次和再次 ARS 均可显著改善 GERD 健康相关生活质量。