Colciago Elisabetta, Merazzi Beatrice, Panzeri Maria, Fumagalli Simona, Nespoli Antonella
School of Medicine and Surgery, University of Milano-Bicocca, Monza, Italy.
Foundation MBBM, Monza, Italy.
Eur J Midwifery. 2020 May 12;4:18. doi: 10.18332/ejm/120003. eCollection 2020.
The aim of this scoping review is to explore the concept of 'vulnerability' affecting pregnant women and to identify an appropriate definition of this term.
Five stages were adopted for conducting the scoping review. A literature search was undertaken between 1 October 2017 and 5 January 2018, using three databases. Relevant publications were appraised, and semantic content analysis was performed to identify emergent themes and four determinants of the vulnerability concept. This involved combining items that seem to address the same issue.
Eleven publications were considered, and eight definitions of vulnerability were identified, and from these four themes emerged: poor health outcome or status; exposure to risk; complex social needs; and lack of resources. Further analysis of evidence found examples of groups of people considered to be vulnerable; they were reported into six matrices, mainly with social and psychological difficulties. From these, eleven themes arose. Following a semantic and content analysis of all themes, thirteen final themes were identified. They represent the characteristics associated with women considered to be vulnerable and are called indices of vulnerability. Semantic and content analysis allowed addressing the thirteen indices of vulnerability into four categories called determinants of the vulnerability concept: deficiency, need, risk exposure, and barriers.
The vulnerability could be defined as a lack of health, related to the presence of at least one of the four determinants. Midwives are the key to identify vulnerable women, offering appropriate care.
本范围综述的目的是探讨影响孕妇的“脆弱性”概念,并确定该术语的适当定义。
采用五个阶段进行范围综述。于2017年10月1日至2018年1月5日期间使用三个数据库进行文献检索。对相关出版物进行评估,并进行语义内容分析以确定新出现的主题以及脆弱性概念的四个决定因素。这涉及合并似乎解决同一问题的项目。
共考虑了11篇出版物,确定了8个脆弱性定义,并由此产生了四个主题:健康结果或状况不佳;暴露于风险;复杂的社会需求;以及资源匮乏。对证据的进一步分析发现了被认为脆弱的人群示例;它们被归纳为六个矩阵,主要涉及社会和心理困难。由此产生了11个主题。在对所有主题进行语义和内容分析之后,确定了13个最终主题。它们代表了与被认为脆弱的女性相关的特征,被称为脆弱性指标。语义和内容分析使我们能够将这13个脆弱性指标归纳为四个类别,即脆弱性概念的决定因素:缺陷、需求、风险暴露和障碍。
脆弱性可定义为与四个决定因素中至少一个因素的存在相关的健康缺失。助产士是识别脆弱女性并提供适当护理的关键。