Department of Sociology, University of Vienna, Austria.
Department of Statistics, Computer Science, Applications (DISIA), University of Florence, Italy.
J Gerontol B Psychol Sci Soc Sci. 2022 Feb 3;77(2):446-455. doi: 10.1093/geronb/gbab021.
Provision of grandchild care has been found to be associated with a youthful subjective age. Yet, previous studies on this topic were cross-sectional and ignored the increasing proportions of older people growing old without the opportunity to become a grandparent. This study investigates the effects of childcare to grandchildren and to other children on subjective age using panel data.
We exploit the longitudinal nature of data from the German Ageing Survey (DEAS) to examine the association between grandparental childcare and care to other children with subjective age, using fixed-effects regression analyses on a sample of 50-85 years old individuals (men: N = 11,151; n = 3,984; women: N = 10,687; n = 3,746, where N is the number of observations and n is the number of individuals).
The results from cross-sectional analyses show a "rejuvenating effect" of provision of both types of childcare in later life, especially for women. However, longitudinal analyses find very small and statistically insignificant effects.
We show for the first time that both grandchild care and childcare outside the grandparent-grandchild relationship are associated with a youthful subjective age for older people. However, these associations are likely due to selection effects, that is, unobserved characteristics of people that make them more likely to engage in childcare and are also associated with subjective age. Our results warn against causal interpretation of associations found in previous studies, but also open up new research questions on the role played by childcare other than to grandchildren.
研究表明,照顾孙辈与主观年龄年轻化有关。然而,之前关于这个主题的研究都是横断面的,忽略了越来越多的老年人没有机会成为祖父母而逐渐变老的情况。本研究使用面板数据调查了照顾孙辈和其他儿童对主观年龄的影响。
我们利用德国老龄化调查(DEAS)的纵向数据,使用固定效应回归分析,在 50-85 岁的个体样本(男性:N = 11151;n = 3984;女性:N = 10687;n = 3746,其中 N 是观察次数,n 是个体数)中,检验了祖辈照顾孙辈和照顾其他儿童与主观年龄之间的关系。
横断面分析的结果表明,在晚年提供这两种类型的育儿都有“年轻化效应”,尤其是对女性而言。然而,纵向分析发现效果非常小且无统计学意义。
我们首次表明,照顾孙辈和照顾祖孙关系以外的儿童都与老年人的年轻主观年龄有关。然而,这些关联可能是由于选择效应,即那些更有可能从事育儿工作且与主观年龄相关的未观察到的个体特征所致。我们的结果警告不要对之前研究中发现的关联进行因果解释,但也为除了照顾孙辈以外的育儿作用这一全新的研究问题提供了新的研究方向。