Siddiqui Mariah, Shah Parth V, Balani Prachi, Lopez Angel R, Nobleza Chelsea Mae N, Khan Safeera
Neurology, St. George's University, True Blue, GRD.
Neurology, California Institute of Behavioral Neurosciences & Psychology, Fairfield, USA.
Cureus. 2021 Jan 30;13(1):e13002. doi: 10.7759/cureus.13002.
Both calcitonin gene-related peptide (CGRP) monoclonal antibodies (mAbs) and OnabotulinumtoxinA (botox) are used in the prevention of chronic migraines. However, it is not clear which is more effective overall. This review will compare the efficacy, side effects, cost-effectiveness, and other factors between CGRP mAbs and botox. We searched Pubmed and Google Scholar using the keywords migraines, CGRP mAbs, botox, efficacy, side effects, aura. All articles, including case-control/cohort studies, case series, case reports, randomized control trials, traditional/systematic reviews, were analyzed. CGRP mAbs and botox both reduce the frequency of migraines in patients. Patients have reported they decreased migraines' frequency and intensity in several studies after being given each medication. While CGRP mAbs are more recent medications, botox has been studied for more than a decade as a migraine preventative. Both drugs have minor short-term side effects, but some CGRP mAbs may cause persistent constipation too. CGRP mAbs are self-injected every month, and botox is physician-injected every three months, making it easier to stay compliant. While both medications are expensive, botox has a lower cost over time. Botox is more effective prophylaxis of migraines based on the articles that were reviewed. While both CGRP mAbs and botox are efficacious and tolerable, botox has been studied longer, has fewer side effects, is more cost-effective, and is easier to comply with.
降钙素基因相关肽(CGRP)单克隆抗体(mAbs)和A型肉毒毒素(保妥适)都用于预防慢性偏头痛。然而,总体上哪种更有效尚不清楚。本综述将比较CGRP单克隆抗体和保妥适之间的疗效、副作用、成本效益及其他因素。我们使用关键词偏头痛、CGRP单克隆抗体、保妥适、疗效、副作用、先兆在PubMed和谷歌学术上进行了搜索。对所有文章进行了分析,包括病例对照/队列研究、病例系列、病例报告、随机对照试验、传统/系统评价。CGRP单克隆抗体和保妥适都能降低患者偏头痛的发作频率。在几项研究中,患者报告在使用每种药物后偏头痛的发作频率和强度都有所降低。虽然CGRP单克隆抗体是较新的药物,但保妥适作为偏头痛预防药物已被研究了十多年。两种药物都有轻微的短期副作用,但一些CGRP单克隆抗体可能还会导致持续性便秘。CGRP单克隆抗体每月自行注射,保妥适每三个月由医生注射一次,后者更易于坚持治疗。虽然两种药物都很昂贵,但从长期来看保妥适成本更低。根据所综述的文章,保妥适对偏头痛的预防性治疗更有效。虽然CGRP单克隆抗体和保妥适都有效且耐受性良好,但保妥适的研究时间更长,副作用更少,成本效益更高,也更易于坚持治疗。