Collaboration for Evidence, Research and Impact in Public Health (CERIPH), Curtin University, Bentley, WA, Australia.
School of Population Health, Curtin University, Bentley, WA, Australia.
Health Promot J Austr. 2022 Jan;33(1):71-82. doi: 10.1002/hpja.466. Epub 2021 Mar 23.
Ethical values underpin the health promotion discipline and profession, and competencies required for professional practice. Understanding how ethical values are translated into professional practice is critical. The aim of this exploratory sequential mixed methods study was to explore Australian health promotion stakeholder perspectives about ethical health promotion practice.
A face-to-face group-based workshop (n = 15), online survey (n = 77) and in-depth individual interviews (n = 15) collected qualitative and quantitative data from health promotion stakeholders. Descriptive statistics were used to analyse quantitative and thematic analysis to analyse qualitative data.
Tensions emerged regarding the nomenclature of ethical health promotion practice, with ethics framed largely by participants as related to formal approval for research. A range of barriers and enablers to ethical practice were identified. Barriers related to obtaining ethical approvals and working with specific population groups and communities. Enablers included professional development opportunities, access to a specialised human research ethics committee and a better understanding of what is meant by 'ethical practice'.
Findings suggest the need for an ethical health promotion practice framework and resources for practitioners and organisations throughout Australia. We propose a framework comprising two pillars: (a) developing critical practice; and (b) building the evidence-based for health promotion. SO WHAT?: This study recognises the need for increased dialogue about the ethical foundations of health promotion. The development of a health promotion ethics framework can better support the development of ethical practice in the Australian health promotion discipline and profession.
伦理价值观是健康促进学科和专业的基础,也是专业实践所需的能力。了解如何将伦理价值观转化为专业实践至关重要。本探索性序贯混合方法研究的目的是探讨澳大利亚健康促进利益相关者对道德健康促进实践的看法。
通过面对面的小组研讨会(n=15)、在线调查(n=77)和深入的个人访谈(n=15),从健康促进利益相关者那里收集定性和定量数据。描述性统计用于分析定量数据,主题分析用于分析定性数据。
关于道德健康促进实践的术语出现了紧张局面,伦理主要由参与者框架为与研究的正式批准有关。确定了一系列道德实践的障碍和促进因素。障碍与获得伦理批准以及与特定人群和社区合作有关。促进因素包括专业发展机会、获得专门的人类研究伦理委员会以及更好地理解“道德实践”的含义。
研究结果表明,澳大利亚各地的从业者和组织都需要一个道德健康促进实践框架和资源。我们提出了一个由两个支柱组成的框架:(a)发展批判性实践;(b)为健康促进建立循证基础。那么,这意味着什么呢?这项研究认识到需要就健康促进的伦理基础进行更多的对话。制定健康促进伦理框架可以更好地支持澳大利亚健康促进学科和专业中伦理实践的发展。