Pesaresi Martino, Corbane Christina, Ren Chao, Edward Ng
European Commission, Joint Research Centre (JRC), Directorate for Space, Security & Migration, Ispra, Italy.
Faculty of Architecture, The University of Hong Kong, Pokfulam, Hong Kong SAR.
PLoS One. 2021 Feb 10;16(2):e0244478. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0244478. eCollection 2021.
The estimation of the vertical components of built-up areas from free Digital Elevation Model (DEM) global data filtered by multi-scale convolutional, morphological and textural transforms are generalized at the spatial resolution of 250 meters using linear least-squares regression techniques. Six test cases were selected: Hong Kong, London, New York, San Francisco, Sao Paulo, and Toronto. Five global DEM and two DEM composites are evaluated in terms of 60 combinations of linear, morphological and textural filtering and different generalization techniques. Four generalized vertical components estimates of built-up areas are introduced: the Average Gross Building Height (AGBH), the Average Net Building Height (ANBH), the Standard Deviation of Gross Building Height (SGBH), and the Standard Deviation of Net Building Height (SNBH). The study shows that the best estimation of the net GVC of built-up areas given by the ANBH and SNBH, always contains a greater error than their corresponding gross GVC estimation given by the AGBH and SGBH, both in terms of mean and standard deviation. Among the sources evaluated in this study, the best DEM source for estimating the GVC of built-up areas with univariate linear regression techniques is a composite of the 1-arcsec Shuttle Radar Topography Mission (SRTM30) and the Advanced Land Observing Satellite (ALOS) World 3D-30 m (AW3D30) using the union operator (CMP_SRTM30-AW3D30_U). A multivariate linear model was developed using 16 satellite features extracted from the CMP_SRTM30-AW3D30_U enriched by other land cover sources, to estimate the gross GVC. A RMSE of 2.40 m and 3.25 m was obtained for the AGBH and the SGBH, respectively. A similar multivariate linear model was developed to estimate the net GVC. A RMSE of 6.63 m and 4.38 m was obtained for the ANBH and the SNBH, respectively. The main limiting factors on the use of the available global DEMs for estimating the GVC of built-up areas are two. First, the horizontal resolution of these sources (circa 30 and 90 meters) corresponds to a sampling size that is larger than the expected average horizontal size of built-up structures as detected from nadir-angle Earth Observation (EO) data, producing more reliable estimates for gross vertical components than for net vertical component of built-up areas. Second, post-production processing targeting Digital Terrain Model specifications may purposely filter out the information on the vertical component of built-up areas that are contained in the global DEMs. Under the limitations of the study presented here, these results show a potential for using global DEM sources in order to derive statistically generalized parameters describing the vertical characteristics of built-up areas, at the scale of 250x250 meters. However, estimates need to be evaluated in terms of the specific requirements of target applications such as spatial population modelling, urban morphology, climate studies and so on.
利用线性最小二乘回归技术,在250米的空间分辨率下,对通过多尺度卷积、形态学和纹理变换滤波的免费数字高程模型(DEM)全球数据中的建成区垂直分量进行估计。选择了六个测试案例:香港、伦敦、纽约、旧金山、圣保罗和多伦多。针对线性、形态学和纹理滤波的60种组合以及不同的概括技术,对五个全球DEM和两个DEM合成数据进行了评估。引入了建成区垂直分量的四种概括估计值:平均总建筑高度(AGBH)、平均净建筑高度(ANBH)、总建筑高度标准差(SGBH)和净建筑高度标准差(SNBH)。研究表明,无论是均值还是标准差,ANBH和SNBH给出的建成区净全球体积含量(GVC)的最佳估计值,始终比AGBH和SGBH给出的相应总GVC估计值包含更大的误差。在本研究评估的数据源中,使用单变量线性回归技术估计建成区GVC的最佳DEM源是使用并集算子(CMP_SRTM30-AW3D30_U)的1弧秒航天飞机雷达地形测绘任务(SRTM30)和先进陆地观测卫星(ALOS)世界3D-30米(AW3D30)的合成数据。利用从CMP_SRTM30-AW3D30_U中提取并由其他土地覆盖源增强的16个卫星特征,建立了一个多元线性模型来估计总GVC。AGBH和SGBH的均方根误差(RMSE)分别为2.40米和3.25米。建立了一个类似的多元线性模型来估计净GVC。ANBH和SNBH的RMSE分别为6.63米和4.38米。使用现有全球DEM估计建成区GVC的主要限制因素有两个。首先,这些数据源的水平分辨率(约30米和90米)对应的采样大小大于从天底角度地球观测(EO)数据中检测到的建成结构的预期平均水平大小,因此对总垂直分量的估计比对建成区净垂直分量的估计更可靠。其次,针对数字地形模型规范的后期处理可能会有意滤除全球DEM中包含的建成区垂直分量信息。在此处提出的研究的局限性下,这些结果表明在250×250米的尺度上,利用全球DEM源来推导描述建成区垂直特征的统计概括参数具有潜力。然而,估计值需要根据目标应用(如空间人口建模、城市形态学、气候研究等)的具体要求进行评估。