Shi Xiu-Yu, Wang Jing, Zhang Wei-Na, Zhao Meng, Ju Jun, Li Xiao-Yan, Lu Qian, Wang Bin, Zou Li-Ping
Department of Pediatrics, The First Medical Center, Chinese PLA General Hospital, Beijing, China.
Department of Pediatrics, Beijing Friendship Hospital, Capital Medical University, Beijing, China.
Front Pediatr. 2021 Jan 25;8:586957. doi: 10.3389/fped.2020.586957. eCollection 2020.
Cesarean section (CS) use has reached a frequency well-above what is expected on the basis of obstetric indications. The large increase in CS use, often for non-medical indications, is of concern given the risks for both women and children. Research about the influence of CS on children's behavior is not new, but most studies didn't differentiate CS due to social factors (such as fear of labor pain, auspicious dates, etc.) from CS with medical indications. Medical indications for CS include fetal distress and intrauterine hypoxia, which may also affect the mental and physical health of the children, thus be a confounding factor. In China, a significant proportion of women undergo CS because of social factors, which provides us a good model to study whether non-fetal triggered delivery will affect children's behavior. Thus, we assessed the impact of CS due to social factors on child psychology and behavior. We conducted a retrospective cohort study. Children were divided into three groups according to delivery mode: vaginal delivery (VD), CS with medical indications, and CS due to social factors (also called as elective cesarean section, ECS). Parents or guardians were required to complete four rating scales of Chinese version [Conners' Parent Rating Scale (CPRS), Child Behavior Checklist-Parent Form (CBCL-PF), Swanson, Nolan, and Pelham rating scale-Parent Form (SNAP-IV-PF), and Behavior Rating Inventory of Executive Function-Parent Form (BRIEF-PF)] on psychological and behavioral problems regarding their children. Among the 38,780 children aged 7-15 years, 29,103 (75.05%) were delivered by VD and 9,677 (24.95%) were delivered by CS (7,844 with medical indications; 1,833 by ECS). Ten covariates were found to significantly affect ECS. Four rating scales were used in this study: CPRS, CBCL-PF, SNAP-IV-PF, and BRIEF-PF. ECS affected child psychology and behavior in several aspects including inattention, hyperactivity/impulsivity, social problems, and executive dysfunction. Regarding to inattention, the ECS group had a higher SNAP-IV-PF inattention score ( = 0.03), compared with the VD group. Logistic multivariate stepwise regression analysis showed that in the ECS group, the ORs were 1.20 in the partially adjusted analyses of SNAP-IV-PF and CPRS. Regarding to social problems, ECS group had a higher CBCL-PF score for the social problems category compared with the VD group ( = 0.0001). Kruskal-Wallis rank sum tests showed that the ECS group had higher BRIEF-PF scores regarding Working Memory ( = 0.04), and Organize ( = 0.01) compared with the VD group. CS affected the offspring's psychology and behavior. After removing possible influence of medical indications, the effect of CS due to social factors on the offspring's psychology and behavior still exists.
剖宫产(CS)的使用频率已远超基于产科指征所预期的水平。剖宫产使用量的大幅增加,通常是出于非医学指征,鉴于其对母婴双方都存在风险,这令人担忧。关于剖宫产对儿童行为影响的研究并非新鲜事,但大多数研究并未区分因社会因素(如害怕分娩疼痛、吉日等)导致的剖宫产和有医学指征的剖宫产。剖宫产的医学指征包括胎儿窘迫和宫内缺氧,这也可能影响儿童的身心健康,从而成为一个混杂因素。在中国,很大一部分女性因社会因素接受剖宫产,这为我们研究非胎儿触发分娩是否会影响儿童行为提供了一个良好的模型。因此,我们评估了因社会因素导致的剖宫产对儿童心理和行为的影响。我们进行了一项回顾性队列研究。根据分娩方式将儿童分为三组:阴道分娩(VD)、有医学指征的剖宫产以及因社会因素导致的剖宫产(也称为选择性剖宫产,ECS)。要求父母或监护人完成四份中文版评定量表[康纳斯父母评定量表(CPRS)、儿童行为清单-父母版(CBCL-PF)、斯旺森、诺兰和佩勒姆评定量表-父母版(SNAP-IV-PF)以及执行功能行为评定量表-父母版(BRIEF-PF)],以评估其子女的心理和行为问题。在38780名7至15岁的儿童中,29103名(75.05%)通过阴道分娩,9677名(24.95%)通过剖宫产(7844名有医学指征;1833名因选择性剖宫产)。发现有十个协变量对选择性剖宫产有显著影响。本研究使用了四份评定量表:CPRS、CBCL-PF、SNAP-IV-PF和BRIEF-PF。选择性剖宫产在多个方面影响儿童心理和行为,包括注意力不集中、多动/冲动、社交问题和执行功能障碍。在注意力不集中方面,与阴道分娩组相比,选择性剖宫产组的SNAP-IV-PF注意力不集中得分更高(P = 0.03)。逻辑多元逐步回归分析显示,在选择性剖宫产组中,在对SNAP-IV-PF和CPRS进行部分调整分析时,比值比为1.20。在社交问题方面,与阴道分娩组相比,选择性剖宫产组在社交问题类别上的CBCL-PF得分更高(P = 0.0001)。克鲁斯卡尔-沃利斯秩和检验显示,与阴道分娩组相比,选择性剖宫产组在工作记忆(P = 0.04)和组织能力(P = 0.01)方面的BRIEF-PF得分更高。剖宫产会影响后代的心理和行为。在排除医学指征的可能影响后,因社会因素导致的剖宫产对后代心理和行为的影响仍然存在。