Utrecht University, Netherlands.
Hist Psychiatry. 2021 Jun;32(2):227-239. doi: 10.1177/0957154X21989174. Epub 2021 Feb 11.
This article demonstrates how psychoanalytic thought, especially ideas by Adler, Reik, Deutsch, and Alexander and Staub, informed forensic psychiatry in the Netherlands from the late 1920s. An analysis of psychiatric explanations of the crime of infanticide shows how in these cases the focus of (forensic) medicine and psychiatry shifted from somatic medicine to a psychoanalytic emphasis on unconscious motives. A psychoanalytic vocabulary can also be found in the reports written by forensic psychiatrists and psychologists in court cases in the 1950s. The new psychoanalytic emphasis on unconscious motives implied a stronger focus on the personality of the suspect. This article argues that psychoanalysis accelerated this development in the mid-twentieth century, contributing to the role of the psy-sciences in normalization processes.
本文展示了从 20 世纪 20 年代后期开始,精神分析思想,尤其是阿德勒、雷克、多伊奇、亚历山大和斯托布的思想,是如何影响荷兰法医精神病学的。对杀婴罪的精神病学解释的分析表明,在这些案例中,(法医)医学和精神病学的关注点从躯体医学转向了对无意识动机的精神分析强调。在 20 世纪 50 年代的法庭案件中,法医精神病学家和心理学家撰写的报告中也可以找到精神分析词汇。新的精神分析对无意识动机的强调意味着更加关注嫌疑人的个性。本文认为,精神分析在 20 世纪中期加速了这一发展,为心理科学在正常化过程中的作用做出了贡献。