Harvard University, USA; University of Cambridge, UK.
Med Hypotheses. 2021 Mar;148:110521. doi: 10.1016/j.mehy.2021.110521. Epub 2021 Jan 28.
Sleep paralysis is a curious condition where the paralyzed person may hallucinate terrifying ghosts. These hypnogogic and hypnopompic visions are common worldwide. They often entail seeing and sensing shadow beings; although hallucinating full-fledged figures (e.g., cat-like creatures and witches) are not uncommon. In this paper, I propose a neuroscientific account (building on previous work) for why people see ghosts during sleep paralysis and why these tend to manifest as faceless shadows. This novel venture considers the distinct computational styles of the right and left hemisphere and their functional specializations vis-à-vis florid intruder hallucinations and out-of-body experiences (OBEs) during these dream-like states. Additionally, I provide a brain-based explanation for dissociative phenomena common during sleep paralysis. Specifically, I posit that these ghost hallucinations and OBEs are chiefly mediated by activity in key regions in the right hemisphere; and outline how the functional organization of the visual system (evoking concepts like surface interpolation) and its economizing nature (i.e., proclivity to minimize computational load and take short-cuts) can explain faceless humanoid-shadows and sensed presence hallucinations during sleep paralysis; and how the hypothalamus and anterior cingulate may be implicated during related dissociative states. Ultimately empirical research must shed light on the validity of this account. If this hypothesis is correct, patients with right hemisphere damage (i.e., in implicated areas) should be less likely to hallucinate ghosts during sleep paralysis; i.e., compared to those with intact hemispheres or damage to the left only. It may also be possible to temporarily disable right hemisphere functions during sleep paralysis using transcranial magnetic stimulation. Accordingly, this procedure should eradicate sleep paralysis ghost hallucinations.
睡眠瘫痪是一种奇特的状态,在这种状态下,瘫痪的人可能会产生可怕的幽灵幻觉。这些催眠和清醒的幻觉在全球范围内都很常见。它们通常涉及到看到和感觉到阴影生物;尽管也会出现完整的人形幻觉(例如,猫科动物和女巫)并不罕见。在本文中,我提出了一个神经科学的解释(基于之前的工作),说明为什么人在睡眠瘫痪期间会看到鬼魂,以及为什么这些鬼魂往往表现为没有脸的阴影。这项新颖的研究考虑了左右半球的不同计算风格及其功能专业化,以及在这些类似梦境的状态下出现的绚丽入侵者幻觉和出体体验(OBE)。此外,我还提供了一个基于大脑的解释,用于解释睡眠瘫痪期间常见的分离现象。具体来说,我认为这些幽灵幻觉和 OBE 主要是由右半球关键区域的活动介导的;并概述了视觉系统的功能组织(唤起表面插值等概念)及其节约性质(即倾向于最小化计算负载和走捷径)如何解释睡眠瘫痪期间没有脸的人形阴影和感觉到的存在幻觉;以及下丘脑和前扣带可能在相关的分离状态中发挥作用。最终,实证研究必须阐明这一解释的有效性。如果这个假设是正确的,那么右半球受损的患者(即在涉及的区域)在睡眠瘫痪期间不太可能出现幽灵幻觉;即与半球完整或仅左侧受损的患者相比。也可以使用经颅磁刺激术在睡眠瘫痪期间暂时禁用右半球功能。因此,这种方法应该可以消除睡眠瘫痪的幽灵幻觉。