Tzankova Iana, Cicognani Elvira
Department of Psychology, University of Bologna, Bologna, Italy.
Eur J Psychol. 2019 Jun 7;15(2):276-291. doi: 10.5964/ejop.v15i2.1647. eCollection 2019 Jun.
The topic of youth participation in the public sphere has received increasing attention within recent psychological research. The literature remains somewhat fragmented between different conceptualizations varying in their specificity or broadness. The present study aims to map the current state of debate in psychology regarding youth civic and political participation and to identify the prevalent themes that characterize the research in the discipline from 1990 to 2016. A semantic content analysis with the software T-Lab was performed on a corpus of 1,777 publications retrieved from the PsycInfo database. The results highlight the increasing number of academic contributions on the topic, confirming the growing importance of the issue within psychology. The study sheds light on the spheres of participation, in which the discipline has attempted to make a contribution, namely: traditional and online political context, institutional civic education, adolescent development, and rights-based activism. Moreover, the findings reveal the existing opposing priorities of research that focus either on the explanation of specific forms of involvement or on the formation of future citizens. Within the thematic attention to young people's civic and political development, there seem to be two general approaches that see youth in divergent ways: as citizens whose civic capacities are to be fostered or as targets for top-down training interventions. This systematic thematic review calls attention to the disparate ways in which youth participation is being addressed in psychology and highlights the need for greater theoretical integration in the field of study.
青少年参与公共领域这一话题在近期的心理学研究中受到了越来越多的关注。在不同的概念化研究中,文献在特异性或宽泛性方面仍存在一定程度的碎片化。本研究旨在梳理心理学领域关于青少年公民和政治参与的当前辩论状况,并确定1990年至2016年该学科研究的普遍主题。使用T-Lab软件对从PsycInfo数据库检索到的1777篇出版物语料库进行了语义内容分析。结果突出了关于该主题的学术贡献数量不断增加,证实了该问题在心理学领域日益增长的重要性。该研究揭示了该学科试图做出贡献的参与领域,即:传统和在线政治背景、机构公民教育、青少年发展以及基于权利的激进主义。此外,研究结果揭示了现有研究存在的相互对立的重点,要么侧重于解释特定形式的参与,要么侧重于未来公民的形成。在对青少年公民和政治发展的主题关注中,似乎有两种普遍的方法以不同的方式看待青少年:一是将其视为公民能力有待培养的公民,二是将其视为自上而下培训干预的对象。这种系统性的主题综述提请人们注意心理学在处理青少年参与问题上的不同方式,并强调该研究领域需要更大程度的理论整合。