Department of Bioengineering, Imperial College London, London, United Kingdom.
J Biomech. 2021 Mar 30;118:110291. doi: 10.1016/j.jbiomech.2021.110291. Epub 2021 Feb 2.
Kinematics play a vital role in answering both clinical and research questions regarding joint biomechanics. Standardisation of kinematic approaches is important; however, the method that is currently recommended for building the joint coordinate system (JCS) to measure kinematics of the wrist is difficult to implement in vivo. In this study, a series of JCSs were examined and compared to the International Society of Biomechanics (ISB) recommendations in terms of landmark digitisation repeatability, coordinate frame creation repeatability, and secondary rotations during planar motion. No differences were found between the ISB JCS and 338 of 408 of the JCSs proposed in the study, meaning that the proposed alternative can be used without affecting the measured joint angles or repeatability of the JCS. Forearm frames that used a vector between the epicondyles to define the YZ plane of the forearm were found to create JCSs that produced secondary rotations greater than that which would be clinically detectable and thus, they should be avoided when defining a JCS. The remaining 338 coordinate systems can be used interchangeably; consequently, should there be any clinical limitations that result in missing landmarks, alternative coordinate systems can be used. A joint coordinate system created using the radial styloid, ulnar styloid, medial epicondyle, lateral epicondyle, the heads of the second and fifth metacarpal, and the base of the third metacarpal is recommended for quantifying kinematics in vivo.
运动学在回答有关关节生物力学的临床和研究问题方面起着至关重要的作用。运动学方法的标准化很重要;然而,目前推荐用于构建关节坐标系(JCS)以测量手腕运动学的方法在体内难以实施。在这项研究中,检查了一系列 JCS,并根据地标数字化重复性、坐标框架创建重复性以及在平面运动期间的次要旋转,与国际生物力学学会(ISB)的建议进行了比较。在研究中提出的 408 个 JCS 中,ISB JCS 与其中的 338 个没有差异,这意味着可以使用所提出的替代方案而不会影响所测量的关节角度或 JCS 的重复性。发现使用髁间的向量来定义前臂的 YZ 平面的前臂框架会产生大于临床可检测的次要旋转的 JCS,因此,在定义 JCS 时应避免使用它们。其余 338 个坐标系可以互换使用;因此,如果存在任何导致地标缺失的临床限制,可以使用替代的坐标系。建议使用桡骨茎突、尺骨茎突、内侧髁、外侧髁、第二和第五掌骨头以及第三掌骨基底创建关节坐标系,用于在体内量化运动学。