de Deus Lysleine Alves, Neves Rodrigo Vanerson Passos, Corrêa Hugo de Luca, Reis Andrea Lucena, Honorato Fernando Sousa, Silva Victor Lopes, de Araújo Thaís Branquinho, Souza Michel Kendy, Sousa Caio Victor, Simões Herbert Gustavo, Prestes Jonato, Silva Neto Luiz Sinésio, Rodrigues Santos Cláudio Avelino, Melo Gislane Ferreira, Stone Whitley Jo, Rosa Thiago Santos
Graduate Program in Physical Education, Catholic University of Brasília, DF, Brazil.
Bouve College of Health Sciences, Northeastern University, Boston, Massachusetts, USA.
Exp Physiol. 2021 Apr;106(4):1099-1109. doi: 10.1113/EP089341. Epub 2021 Mar 3.
What is the central question of this study? Can resistance training with and without blood flow restriction improve redox balance and positively impact the autonomic cardiac modulation in chronic kidney disease patients? What is the main finding and its importance? Resistance training with and without blood flow restriction improved antioxidant defence (paraoxonase 1), decreased the pro-oxidative myeloperoxidase, improved cardiac autonomic function and slowed the decrease in renal function. We draw attention to the important clinical implications for the management of redox balance and autonomic cardiac function in chronic kidney disease patients.
Patients with chronic kidney disease (CKD) are prone to cardiovascular diseases secondary to abnormalities in both autonomic cardiac function and redox balance [myeloperoxidase (MPO) to paraoxonase 1 (PON1) ratio]. Although aerobic training improves both autonomic balance and redox balance in patients with CKD, the cardioprotective effects of resistance training (RT), with and without blood flow restriction (BFR), remain unknown. We aimed to compare the effects of RT and RT+BFR on antioxidant defence (PON1), pro-oxidative status (MPO), cardiac autonomic function (quantified by heart rate variability analysis) and renal function. Conservative CKD (stages 1 to 5 who do not need hemodialysis) patients (n = 105, 33 female) of both sexes were randomized into three groups: control (CTL; 57.6 ± 5.2 years; body mass index, 33.23 ± 1.62 kg/m ), RT (58.09 ± 6.26 years; body mass index 33.63 ± 2.05 kg/m ) and RT+BFR (58.06 ± 6.47 years; body mass index, 33.32 ± 1.87 kg/m ). Patients completed 6 months of RT or RT+BFR on three non-consecutive days per week under the supervision of strength and conditioning professionals. Training loads were adjusted every 2 months. Heart rate variability was recorded with a Polar-RS800 and data were analysed for time and frequency domains using Kubios software. The redox balance markers were PON1 and MPO, which were analysed in plasma samples. Renal function was estimated as estimated glomerular filtration rate. The RT and RT+BFR decreased pro-oxidative MPO (RT, ∼34 ng/ml and RT+BFR, ∼27 ng/ml), improved both antioxidant defence (PON1: RT, ∼23 U/L and RT+BFR, ∼31 U/L) and cardiac autonomic function (R-R interval: RT, ∼120.4 ms and RT+BFR, ∼117.7 ms), and slowed the deterioration of renal function (P < 0.0001). Redox balance markers were inversely correlated with heart rate variability time-domain indices. Our data indicated that both training models were effective as non-pharmacological tools to increase the antioxidant defences, decrease oxidative stress and improve the cardiac autonomic function of CKD patients.
本研究的核心问题是什么?有或没有血流限制的阻力训练能否改善慢性肾病患者的氧化还原平衡并对心脏自主神经调节产生积极影响?主要发现及其重要性是什么?有或没有血流限制的阻力训练均可改善抗氧化防御能力(对氧磷酶1),降低促氧化的髓过氧化物酶水平,改善心脏自主神经功能,并减缓肾功能下降。我们提请注意这对于慢性肾病患者氧化还原平衡和心脏自主神经功能管理的重要临床意义。
慢性肾病(CKD)患者由于心脏自主神经功能和氧化还原平衡(髓过氧化物酶(MPO)与对氧磷酶1(PON1)的比值)异常,易患心血管疾病。尽管有氧运动可改善CKD患者的自主神经平衡和氧化还原平衡,但有或没有血流限制(BFR)的阻力训练(RT)对心脏的保护作用仍不清楚。我们旨在比较RT和RT+BFR对抗氧化防御(PON1)、促氧化状态(MPO)、心脏自主神经功能(通过心率变异性分析量化)和肾功能的影响。将105例(33例女性)保守治疗的CKD(1至5期,无需血液透析)患者随机分为三组:对照组(CTL;年龄57.6±5.2岁;体重指数,33.23±1.62kg/m²)、RT组(年龄58.09±6.26岁;体重指数33.63±2.05kg/m²)和RT+BFR组(年龄58.06±6.47岁;体重指数,33.32±1.87kg/m²)。患者在力量和体能训练专业人员的监督下,每周三天,连续6个月进行RT或RT+BFR训练。每2个月调整一次训练负荷。使用Polar-RS800记录心率变异性,并使用Kubios软件对时域和频域数据进行分析。氧化还原平衡标志物为PON1和MPO,在血浆样本中进行分析。肾功能以估计的肾小球滤过率来评估。RT和RT+BFR均可降低促氧化的MPO(RT组约为34ng/ml,RT+BFR组约为27ng/ml),改善抗氧化防御能力(PON1:RT组约为23U/L,RT+BFR组约为31U/L)和心脏自主神经功能(RR间期:RT组约为120.4ms,RT+BFR组约为117.7ms),并减缓肾功能恶化(P<0.0001)。氧化还原平衡标志物与心率变异性时域指标呈负相关。我们的数据表明,两种训练模式作为非药物工具,均可有效提高CKD患者的抗氧化防御能力,降低氧化应激,改善心脏自主神经功能。