Peterson Cynthia K, Miller Joyce, Humphreys B Kim, Vall Ken
J Chiropr Educ. 2021 Oct 1;35(2):242-248. doi: 10.7899/JCE-20-10.
The European Council on Chiropractic Education (ECCE) currently accredits 10 programs throughout Europe and South Africa. It is assumed that ECCE evaluation activities lead to changes to the chiropractic programs but no systematic evaluation as to whether this is true, and the extent of changes has previously been done. The purpose of this study was to obtain feedback from program heads as to whether ECCE evaluation reports facilitated changes/improvements to their programs and to identify their reported changes.
This was a mixed methods audit study using questionnaires with 2 sections. Closed statements requesting the degree of change to each section of the "Standards" based on ECCE evaluation reports (substantial, some, none) were analyzed using frequencies. Written responses identifying the specific changes made based on previous evaluation reports were evaluated independently by 3 researchers using a modified "thematic analysis" approach.
All 10 accredited programs responded. Seven of the 10 programs (70%) reported "some" or "substantial" changes to ≥ 6 sections of the ECCE Standards. The most common section with reported changes was "Educational Program" (8 of 10). "Educational Resources" had the largest number of programs reporting "substantial changes" (4) and was the second most common section to have reported changes. The main themes identified emphasized changes in "infrastructure, equipment and faculty," "increasing evidence-based practice," and "instilling a research culture in faculty and students."
ECCE accreditation processes facilitate changes to the chiropractic programs, particularly in the areas of improved infrastructure and faculty, research, and evidence-based practice.
欧洲整脊教育理事会(ECCE)目前认可了欧洲和南非的10个项目。据推测,ECCE的评估活动会导致整脊项目发生变化,但此前并未对这是否属实以及变化程度进行系统评估。本研究的目的是从项目负责人那里获得反馈,了解ECCE评估报告是否促进了他们项目的变化/改进,并确定他们报告的变化。
这是一项混合方法的审计研究,使用了包含两个部分的问卷。基于ECCE评估报告,要求对“标准”各部分的变化程度(重大、一些、无)进行封闭式陈述,使用频率进行分析。由3名研究人员使用改良的“主题分析”方法独立评估基于先前评估报告所做具体变化的书面回复。
所有10个获得认可的项目都做出了回应。10个项目中的7个(70%)报告称,ECCE标准的≥6个部分有“一些”或“重大”变化。报告有变化的最常见部分是“教育项目”(10个中有8个)。“教育资源”报告“重大变化”的项目数量最多(4个),是报告有变化的第二常见部分。确定的主要主题强调了“基础设施、设备和师资”、“增加循证实践”以及“在教师和学生中灌输研究文化”方面的变化。
ECCE认证过程促进了整脊项目的变化,特别是在改善基础设施和师资、研究以及循证实践等领域。