Gatenby R A, Kessler H B, Rosenblum J S, Coia L R, Moldofsky P J, Hartz W H, Broder G J
Fox Chase Cancer Center, Philadelphia, PA.
Int J Radiat Oncol Biol Phys. 1988 May;14(5):831-8. doi: 10.1016/0360-3016(88)90002-8.
Oxygen distribution was measured in 31 fixed lymph node metastases (mean diameter 4.4 cm +/- 0.8 cm) from squamous cell carcinoma of the head and neck by passing a needle electrode through each tumor under CT guidance. Thirteen tumors had uniform oxygen distribution with all measurements under 10 mm Hg. Six tumors had uniform oxygen distribution with all measurements above 10 mm Hg, and twelve tumors had variable oxygen distribution with measurements higher in the periphery than in the center. Response to radiation therapy was judged by changes in tumor volume 90 days following completion of therapy compared to pre-therapy volume. Eighteen tumors were considered complete responders (CR); eleven, non-responders (NR); two, partial responders (PR). No statistically significant difference in radiation dose or tumor size was seen in the PR and CR groups. Mean pO2 was 20.6 (+/- 4.4) mm Hg in the CR group and 4.7 (+/- 3.0) mm Hg in the NR group (p less than 0.001). Normalized pO2 content defined as the total tumor oxygen content normalized by dividing by the volume was 37.4 (+/- 8.2) mm Hg in the CR group and 8.2 (+/- 5.1) mm Hg in the NR group (p less than 0.001). The volume and oxygen levels of each tumor were tabulated and analyzed. Twelve tumors had greater than 26% of their volume containing a pO2 less than 8 mm Hg. Eleven of these were NR and one PR. Nineteen tumors had less than 26% of their volume containing a pO2 less than 8 mm Hg. Eighteen were CR and one PR (p less than 0.001). These data suggest that oxygen plays a significant role in human tumor response to radiation therapy. Oxygen measurements appear to allow separation of subgroups of patients with a poor prognosis who would most benefit from maneuvers to circumvent the hypoxic effect.
在CT引导下,将针电极穿过31例头颈部鳞状细胞癌的固定淋巴结转移灶(平均直径4.4 cm±0.8 cm),测量其氧分布。13个肿瘤的氧分布均匀,所有测量值均低于10 mmHg。6个肿瘤的氧分布均匀,所有测量值均高于10 mmHg,12个肿瘤的氧分布不均匀,周边测量值高于中心。根据治疗完成90天后肿瘤体积与治疗前体积的变化来判断对放射治疗的反应。18个肿瘤被认为是完全缓解者(CR);11个为无反应者(NR);2个为部分缓解者(PR)。PR组和CR组在放射剂量或肿瘤大小方面未见统计学显著差异。CR组的平均pO2为20.6(±4.4)mmHg,NR组为4.7(±3.0)mmHg(p<0.001)。以肿瘤总体积归一化的pO2含量,CR组为37.4(±8.2)mmHg,NR组为8.2(±5.1)mmHg(p<0.001)。将每个肿瘤的体积和氧水平制成表格并进行分析。12个肿瘤有超过26%的体积pO2低于8 mmHg。其中11个为NR,1个为PR。19个肿瘤有不到26%的体积pO2低于8 mmHg。18个为CR,1个为PR(p<0.001)。这些数据表明,氧在人类肿瘤对放射治疗的反应中起重要作用。氧测量似乎能够区分出预后较差的亚组患者,这些患者最能从规避缺氧效应的措施中获益。