Sleep to remember, sleep to forget: Rapid eye movement sleep can have inverse effects on recall and generalization of fear memories.

Rapid Eye Movement (REM) sleep has been shown to modulate the consolidation of fear memories, a process that may contribute to the development of Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD). However, contradictory findings have been reported regarding the direction of this modulation and its differential effects on recall versus generalization. In two complementary experiments, we addressed this by employing sleep deprivation protocols together with a novel fear-conditioning paradigm that required the discrimination between coexisting threat and safety signals. Using skin conductance responses and functional imaging (fMRI), we found two opposing effects of REM sleep: While REM impaired recall of the original threat memories, it improved the ability to generalize these memories to novel situations that emphasized the discrimination between threat and safety signals. These results, as well as previous findings in healthy participants and patients diagnosed with PTSD, could be explained by the degree to which the balance between threat and safety signals for a given stimulus was predictive of threat. We suggest that this account can be integrated with contemporary theories of sleep and fear learning, such as the REM recalibration hypothesis.