Mukhalalati Banan Abdulrzaq, Ibrahim Meram Mohamed Mahmoud Elsayed, Al Alawneh Majdoleen Omar, Awaisu Ahmed, Bates Ian, Bader Lina
Clinical Pharmacy and Practice Section, College of Pharmacy, QU Health, Qatar University, P.O. Box 2713, Doha, Qatar.
College of Pharmacy, Qatar University, Doha, Qatar.
J Pharm Policy Pract. 2021 Feb 22;14(1):22. doi: 10.1186/s40545-021-00305-y.
The sustainable development goals were launched by the United Nations in 2015. Its fifth goal was describing the achievement of universal health coverage by 2030. This goal reaffirms the importance of investing in the development and training of the global health workforce. In alliance with this, the International Pharmaceutical Federation (FIP) has published reports about pharmacy workforce planning in several countries. However, data about Qatar were not included in these reports. In 2017, FIP developed a transformational roadmap of pharmaceutical workforce and education. One systematic framework component of the roadmap is the Pharmaceutical Workforce Development Goals (DG[w]s) that were released in late 2016 and subsequently incorporated into the more comprehensive Global Development Goals in 2020, encompassing not only workforce development, but additionally practice and pharmaceutical science development. This study aimed to evaluate the current situation of pharmacy workforce and education in Qatar in relation to the original 13 Pharmaceutical Workforce Development Goals (DG[w]s). The objective was to identify the gaps in pharmacy workforce and education and to recommend evidence-led strategies to be included in both the Ministry of Public Health and the Qatar University College of Pharmacy workforce development plans.
Three rounds of conventional Delphi technique were conducted with expert panels of key decision-makers in pharmacy practice from the College of Pharmacy at Qatar University and the Ministry of Public Health, utilizing the FIP's self-assessment survey. Qualitative content analysis was used to analyze and prioritize the identified gaps from the collected data. DG[w] was considered "met" if all the provided indicators were achieved, "partially met" if at least one of the indicators were achieved, and "not met" if none of the indicators were achieved RESULTS: The lack of competency framework (DG[w]5), workforce data (DG[w]12), and workforce policy formation (DG[w]13) are three major gaps in the provision of pharmaceutical workforce and pharmacy education in Qatar, influencing other DG[w]s. These gaps need to be addressed by the formation of Qatar Pharmaceutical Association through which academic, practice, and policymaking sectors can work together in developing health workforce intelligence system.
The results indicated that DG[w]s are interrelated and a gap in one goal can negatively influence others. Results and recommendations of this research will facilitate the implementation of strategic plans across leading pharmacy sectors to meet health needs in Qatar and achieve the third pillar of the Qatar National Vision 2030.
联合国于2015年发起了可持续发展目标。其第五个目标是描述到2030年实现全民健康覆盖。该目标重申了投资于全球卫生人力发展和培训的重要性。与此相关,国际药学联合会(FIP)发布了有关多个国家药学人力规划的报告。然而,这些报告未包含卡塔尔的数据。2017年,FIP制定了药学人力与教育的转型路线图。该路线图的一个系统框架组成部分是2016年末发布的药学人力发展目标(DG[w]s),并于2020年随后纳入更全面的全球发展目标,不仅涵盖人力发展,还包括实践和药学科学发展。本研究旨在评估卡塔尔药学人力与教育的现状与最初的13项药学人力发展目标(DG[w]s)的关系。目的是找出药学人力与教育方面的差距,并推荐以证据为导向的策略纳入公共卫生部和卡塔尔大学药学院的人力发展计划。
利用FIP的自我评估调查,与卡塔尔大学药学院和公共卫生部的药学实践关键决策者专家小组进行了三轮传统德尔菲技术。采用定性内容分析法对收集数据中确定的差距进行分析和排序。如果所有提供的指标都实现,则DG[w]被视为“实现”;如果至少实现了一个指标,则视为“部分实现”;如果没有指标实现,则视为“未实现”。结果:缺乏能力框架(DG[w]5)、人力数据(DG[w]12)和人力政策制定(DG[w]13)是卡塔尔药学人力和药学教育提供方面的三个主要差距,影响其他DG[w]s。这些差距需要通过成立卡塔尔药学协会来解决,通过该协会,学术、实践和决策部门可以共同努力开发卫生人力情报系统。
结果表明DG[w]s相互关联,一个目标的差距会对其他目标产生负面影响。本研究的结果和建议将有助于在主要药学部门实施战略计划,以满足卡塔尔的卫生需求并实现《卡塔尔2030国家愿景》的第三大支柱。