Division of Pediatric Cardiology, Loma Linda University Children's Hospital, Loma Linda, California, United States.
Division of Internal Medicine, Belau National Hospital and Ministry of Health, Koror, Republic of Palau.
J Paediatr Child Health. 2021 Jul;57(7):1089-1095. doi: 10.1111/jpc.15409. Epub 2021 Feb 24.
Non-expert training in rheumatic heart disease (RHD) detection is a valuable strategy in resource-limited settings. Here we present an innovative handheld ultrasound application featuring views of correct probe position, imaging protocol and echocardiographic loops of RHD pathology versus normal, accessible during real-time scanning.
This prospective study was implemented into a pre-existing school health screening programme at an elementary school in Koror, Palau. Six learners with no prior ultrasound experience were taught a simplified screening protocol in which a mitral regurgitation jet ≥1.5 cm and/or presence of aortic insufficiency were considered a positive screen. All consented children underwent echocardiographic screening by experts with standard portable echocardiography. All positive cases and 25% of negative cases were referred for handheld scans by learners.
A total of 26 (4.1%) children were diagnosed with borderline or definite RHD. Mean sensitivity and specificity compared to expert RHD diagnosis over all learners was 71% (standard deviation (SD) 11.3) and 92% (SD 4.9), respectively. For the three highest scanning learners, mean sensitivity was 88% (SD 4.9) and mean specificity was 90% (SD 5.7). For all definite RHD cases, sensitivity was 100% for all but one learner, who achieved sensitivity of 60%. The novel application was used in 229 of 624 (36%) of all handheld scans and 50 of 112 (45%) of expert-diagnosed positive scans, with protocol and reference features most frequently used. Utilisation of the novel application overall decreased per day of scanning per learner.
Adjunctive handheld ultrasound technology may help ease non-experts into RHD screening.
在资源有限的情况下,对风湿性心脏病(RHD)检测进行非专业培训是一种有价值的策略。在这里,我们介绍了一种创新的手持式超声应用程序,该程序具有正确的探头位置、成像协议以及 RHD 病理学与正常超声心动图循环的视图,可在实时扫描过程中使用。
这项前瞻性研究是在帕劳科罗尔的一所小学现有的学校健康筛查计划中实施的。六名没有超声经验的学习者接受了简化的筛查方案培训,其中二尖瓣反流射流≥1.5cm 和/或存在主动脉瓣关闭不全被认为是阳性筛查。所有同意的儿童都由专家使用标准便携式超声心动图进行超声心动图筛查。所有阳性病例和 25%的阴性病例都由学习者进行手持式扫描。
共有 26 名(4.1%)儿童被诊断为边缘性或明确性 RHD。所有学习者的平均敏感性和特异性与专家 RHD 诊断相比分别为 71%(标准差 11.3)和 92%(标准差 4.9)。对于三名最高水平的扫描学习者,平均敏感性为 88%(标准差 4.9),平均特异性为 90%(标准差 5.7)。对于所有明确的 RHD 病例,除一名学习者的敏感性为 60%外,所有其他学习者的敏感性均为 100%。该新型应用程序用于 624 次手持式扫描中的 229 次(36%)和专家诊断阳性扫描中的 112 次中的 50 次(45%),最常使用协议和参考特征。随着每天扫描学习者人数的增加,新型应用程序的使用率总体下降。
辅助手持式超声技术可以帮助非专业人员进行 RHD 筛查。