Department of Anesthesia and Perioperative Care, University of California San Francisco, San Francisco, CA, USA.
Department of Epidemiology and Biostatistics, University of California San Francisco, San Francisco, CA, USA.
J Clin Monit Comput. 2022 Apr;36(2):473-482. doi: 10.1007/s10877-021-00675-3. Epub 2021 Mar 2.
Opioid-induced respiratory depression (OIRD) confers significant morbidity, but its onset can be challenging to recognize. Pain or stimulation effects of conversation may mask or attenuate common clinical manifestations of OIRD. We asked whether pupillary unrest could provide an objective signal of opioid exposure, and whether this signal would be independent from the confounding influence of extrinsic stimulation. We conducted a cross-over trial of healthy volunteers using identical remifentanil infusions separated by a washout period; in both, pupillary unrest in ambient light (PUAL) was measured at 2.5-min intervals. During one infusion, investigators continuously engaged the subject in conversation, while in the other, a quiet environment was maintained; measures of respiratory depression were compared under each condition. We tested PUAL's relationship to estimated opioid concentration under quiet conditions, measured PUAL's discrimination of lower versus higher opioid exposure using receiver operating characteristic (ROC) analysis, and assessed the effect of stimulation on PUAL versus opioid using mixed effects regression. Respiratory depression occurred more frequently under quiet conditions (p < 0.0001). Under both conditions, PUAL declined significantly over the course of the remifentanil infusion and rose during recovery (p < 0.0001). PUAL showed excellent discrimination in distinguishing higher versus absent-moderate opioid exposure (AUROC = 0.957 [0.929 to 0.985]), but was unaffected by interactive versus quiet conditions (mean difference, interactive - quiet = - 0.007, 95% CI - 0.016 to 0.002). PUAL is a consistent indicator of opioid effect, and distinguishes higher opioid concentrations independently of the stimulating effects of conversational interaction. Under equivalent opioid exposure, conversational interaction delayed the onset and minimized the severity of OIRD.Clinical trial registration: NCT04301895.
阿片类药物引起的呼吸抑制(OIRD)会导致显著的发病率,但它的发作很难识别。疼痛或谈话的刺激作用可能会掩盖或减轻 OIRD 的常见临床症状。我们想知道瞳孔不安是否能提供阿片类药物暴露的客观信号,以及这种信号是否独立于外在刺激的干扰影响。我们进行了一项健康志愿者的交叉试验,使用相同的瑞芬太尼输注,中间有一个洗脱期;在这两种情况下,在环境光下测量瞳孔不安(PUAL),间隔 2.5 分钟。在一次输注中,研究人员持续与受试者交谈,而在另一次输注中,保持安静的环境;在每种情况下比较呼吸抑制的测量值。我们在安静条件下测试了 PUAL 与估计的阿片类药物浓度的关系,使用接收者操作特征(ROC)分析测试了 PUAL 对较低和较高阿片类药物暴露的区分能力,并使用混合效应回归评估了刺激对 PUAL 与阿片类药物的影响。在安静条件下,呼吸抑制发生的频率更高(p < 0.0001)。在两种情况下,随着瑞芬太尼输注的进行,PUAL 显著下降,在恢复期间上升(p < 0.0001)。在区分更高和无中度阿片类药物暴露方面,PUAL 表现出极好的辨别力(AUROC = 0.957 [0.929 至 0.985]),但不受互动与安静条件的影响(平均差异,互动 - 安静 = - 0.007,95%CI - 0.016 至 0.002)。PUAL 是阿片类药物作用的一致指标,可独立于对话互动的刺激作用区分更高的阿片类药物浓度。在等效的阿片类药物暴露下,对话互动会延迟 OIRD 的发作并最小化其严重程度。临床试验注册:NCT04301895。